European Journal of Social Sciences Studies
ISSN: 2501-8590
ISSN-L: 2501-8590
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/soc
10.5281/zenodo.55247
Volume 1│Issue 1│2016
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL
FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND ISSUES
ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
Assistant Professor, KIIT School of Social Sciences,
(KISS) Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India
Abstract:
The present study intends to highlight the issues and policies of government and its
impact on tribal youth in particular and their families in general to develop their
educational as well as their economic status. At the same time the study, also focus on
the factors responsible for their unemployment along with the suggestions for
improvement in the present status. To explore all these ideas four objectives are framed
along with same number of research questions. After a critical analysis we find that the
present policies and issues made by the government are praise worthy but the
implementation level is not at all fruitful in the grass root level. For that we have made
some suggestions for up-gradation of the present situation for tribals like: strict
implementation of reservation of seats in public sector employment, proper looking into
reservation of seats in institutions of higher learning, formulation of proper welfare
schemes for prosperity of tribals based on fact data, in private sector also these should
be reservations for schedule tribes. The present 7.5% of reservation for government
services should be increased whenever necessary.
Keywords: unemployment, tribal education, family education, government policies
Introduction
India enjoys a demographic dividend where more than 50 per cent of its population is
in the working age group of 15 to 59 and 28 per cent in age group 15-29. It is expected
that by the year 2020, more than 65 per cent of the Indian population would be in the
Correspondence: Rasmi Ranjan Puhan, email: rasmi.lakshmi@gmail.com
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved
Published by Open Access Publishing Group ©2015.
21
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
working age group and India would enjoy the demographic dividend. The table
provides details of youth population in India:
Numbers in millions
372.4
492.9
333.3
Share
31%
41 %
28%
The demographic dividend offers an economic opportunity to India to be utilized for
fast tracking its growth, particularly in the manufacturing sector. This 12th becomes all
the more important when 12 Plan envisions creation of 50 million non-farm
employment opportunities. However, creating jobs for the youth is a biggest challenge
faced both by developed and developing economies around the world.
The issues of exclusion and discrimination assume special importance in the
Indian context wherein SCs and STs, which together constitute nearly one-fourth of the
Indian population, have traditionally suffered from social exclusion like education and
employment if we see the trend. While these population groups are numerically
important, they continuously lag behind the other social groups in various social,
economic and political indicators of development. In India, more equality of
educational opportunity began to be emphasized in the decades following
Independence in 1947. Policies of protective discrimination for the scheduled groups
emerged as an effort to promote greater minority group access to education and
employment (Kumar 1988). Higher rates of employment reflect greater opportunities to
participate in the economy. It would, however, be misleading to assume that work
participation is voluntary for the bulk of the population of India. But the low standard
of living of the scheduled group s results in employment being required in order to
meet basic needs, thus, for the purpose of this analysis, higher work participation rates
are interpreted as an indication of a higher standard of living, or a higher degree of
socioeconomic development. Present caste-based reservation system of Union
Government.
Category as per
Reservation Percentage as per
Government of India
Government of India
Scheduled Castes (SC)
15%
Scheduled Tribes (ST)
7.5%
Other Backward Classes (OBC)
27%
Total constitutional reservation percentage
49.5%
General (Open to all including SC/ST and OBC)
50.5%
This article focuses on issues of youth employment and unemployment in India
wherein the youth is defined to include the population in the age group 15 to 29. The
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
22
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
available data shows that poverty and low levels of education are the biggest barriers
for the decent employment opportunities for the youth. Being employable in the labour
market remains a distant dream. According to the recent data, youth is one of the
hardest hit segments of the world's population with high unemployment rates across
the globe. Youth unemployment in US is more than 17 per cent where youth constitute
age group 15 to 24. The situation is worse in Europe where youth unemployment in
Greece is approaching 60 per cent followed by Spain 55 per cent, Italy 35 per cent and
France 25 per cent. In the Indian context, as per Census 2011, youth accounts for 28 per
cent of population. Although, the dependency ratio in India is declining, the youth
unemployment remains high. As per the World Bank Report, in India youth
unemployment as a percentage of youth population is 10 per cent for males and 11 per
cent for females. The lack of decent employment opportunities forces youth to take up
self-employment and low paid contractual jobs with deplorable working conditions.
This is evident from the fact that more than 93 per cent of the workforce is employed in
the informal sector. The youth employment has been recognized as a priority agenda of
the government and policies are being framed for enhancing their employability.
Challenges of Youth Employment
India faces a paradoxical situation where, on the one hand, youth is looking for job and
on the other hand, industry is suffering from availability of skilled workers. This skill
mismatch makes youth unemployable. This is a result of supply driven and not
demand driven education system due to lack of interface among different stakeholders
viz. policy makers, industry, training providers and educational institutions. The
training institutes need to educate as per industry's requirements so that demographic
dividend can be tapped fruitfully. It is expected that in a decade, 40 percent of the 15-29
age group will enter the labour force, which needs to be provided with decent
employment opportunities. Further, the manufacturing employment in India has not
increased to the extent desired. In rural areas, majority of the labour force is engaged in
the agriculture sector, indicating almost negligible presence of employment
opportunities outside of agriculture. Any movement of labour force to non-farm sector,
as is envisaged in the 12th Plan, implies either no job or low-productivity-low paid jobs
due to mismatch of skills. There is also a need to increase formal employment, which
presently constitutes about 8 percent of the labour force to circumvent more youth
joining low paid sector and remaining working poor. This poses the question: Is India
ready for this challenge?
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
23
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Review of literature
World Bank
India s labour force makes up about
per cent of the total
population. According to the World Bank, the Indian labour market in the 1990s was
better, despite acceleration in job growth in subsequent years. These conclusions are
based on three main facts: (i) a comparison of job growth over two decades
1983 1994 and 1994 2005
that is,
suggests that job growth was flat at 2 per cent over the long
term; (ii) the spurt in employment since 2000 has been accompanied by a marked
deceleration in real wage growth and even a decline for many workers, implying that
the number of working poor has increased in the past five years; and (iii) low-paying,
relatively unproductive, informal sector jobs continue to dominate the labour market.
The Planning Commission of the Government of India (GOI), in its 11th Five
Year Plan (2007 2012), also concludes that the Indian economy has failed to create
sufficient volume of additional high-quality employment to absorb the new entrants
into the labour market. It has also failed to facilitate the absorption of existing surplus
labour into the agriculture sector, as also into higher wage or non-agriculture
employment (Planning Commission 2008). Ghandially (1988) the most extreme
deprivation exists among women in the scheduled caste and tribe populations, groups
designated as particularly disadvantaged in the Indian Constitution. The minority
group status of these women interacts with India's patriarchal culture to produce
deplorable living conditions. Bhai (1986); Mitra (1979). The government of India views
basic literacy as well as more advanced educational credentials as the necessary first
steps toward the attainment of rewarding positions in the economy and a higher
standard of living for disadvantaged segments of the population.
Rationale of the study
The unemployment of young people in the labour market is high, due to their lack of
marketable education and skills. The unemployment rate for the youth labour force in
India was as high as 8 per cent, according to usual status, in 2004 2005 and it shows an
increasing trend. According to the literacy status of the youth labour force, the
distinction in terms of unemployment rate between literates and illiterates was
significant where the unemployment rate was higher among the literates than that of
the illiterates. In terms of the level of education, the unemployment rate was highest
among young graduates at 35.5 per cent according to the usual status in 2004 2005.
Although the unemployment rate varies with the concepts of unemployment and the
level of education of the youth labour force, the difference in the unemployment rate
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
24
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
between three alternative concepts seems to be declining from the lower to the higher
level of education.
Objectives
To study the impact of unemployment on the tribal youth and families;
To highlight the policy issues on education and employment to empower tribal;
To study the highlighted factors obstructing unemployment of tribal youth;
To made some suggestion with regard to tribal education and employment.
Research Questions
Whether unemployment of tribal youth has any impact on their families?
What are the different policies made by govt. on education and employment to
empower tribal s?
What are the emerging factors for unemployment of tribal people in India?
How these policies can have any impact on tribal education and employment?
Methodology
Descriptive survey method used in the study as the investigators tried to get
information about more than one variable also with better understanding of perceptions
of stakeholders (Hittleman and Simon, 1997). Through this method information about
conditions, situations and events that occur in the present can be obtained (UNESCO,
2005).
Therefore, in the present study, the investigator used this method to explore all
possibilities to measure the impact and effectiveness of government implemented
policies and issues with regarding to the tribal employment and education, Also the
problems and its eradication from the root.
Secondary data collection
The sources of secondary data are the published and unpublished reports. Data from
secondary sources were gathered from books, articles, journals, published reports, and
Government documents. Quantitative information with regard to current impact, issues
on integrated policies and issues on tribal employment.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
25
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Discussion
To study the impact of unemployment on the tribal youth and families
The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, Government of India, has
brought out the Millennium Development Goals
India Country Report
, which
shows India s performance with regard to the MDGs, and projects the likely
achievement rates by 2015. Due to the serious disparity in the education and
employment sector MDGs are now miles long gap to achieve for tribal youth. This
unemployment and lack of education have negative impact on their families in
particular and they are miles to go to achieve MDGs in general.
Inadequate Poverty Reduction
How far have the SCs and STs progressed towards attaining the MDGs? The available
official statistics show a gradual progress towards the attainment of many MDGs
including in the case of SCs and STs. However, there is a big gap in the levels of
development between the SCs STs and other social groups. The STs have the highest
incidence of poverty at 32.5 per cent, in 2009 10.
Increase in Inequality
What is the implication of these rising inequalities for SCs and STs? A large proportion
of the SCs and STs are not able to partake of their share in the shining sectors
characterized by high growth
those
of India, which employ about 31 per cent of all workers.
Only 5.2 per cent of the total SC ST workers are benefitting from this shining part of
India Similarly, the enrollment ratio is the lowest and the dropout rate highest in the
lowest quintile groups. Both the SCs and STs together form a large percentage of the
population belonging to the lower quintile groups.
Malnutrition
Despite significant progress in economic growth, India has a widespread incidence of
malnutrition among children below the age of five years-about 42 per cent among them
are underweight and nearly 59 per cent are stunted.27 The incidence of malnutrition is
the highest among STs (54.5 per cent), followed by SCs (47.9 per cent), and other social
groups (36.3 per cent).28 The likelihood of SC children being malnourished is about 1.4
times higher than that of children belonging to other social groups even after
controlling for education and the health of mothers.29 The average annual rate of
reduction in malnutrition was the lowest for STs (0.37 per cent), followed by SCs (1.67
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
26
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
per cent), and the highest (3.14 per cent) for others during the period 1998 99 to 2005
06.
Lack of Universal Primary Education
However, these encouraging developments in enrolment have also been accompanied
by a huge drop-out rate among children due to various reasons. The reasons for dropout among the marginalized students largely include the poor financial conditions of
their parents and their disinterest in studies. Discriminatory practices in schools by both
teachers and peers make studies less attractive for some SC children.38 For STs, the
school infrastructure and language also become major bottlenecks in the continuance of
education. There are few residential schools to cater to the demands of the tribal
students. Lack of infrastructure such as adequate classrooms and separate toilets for girl
students, along with poor teaching resources are the other problems that lead to higher
drop-out rates. It has been found that as many as 50 per cent of the schools do not have
separate toilets for girls. Only 36.5 per cent of the teachers in schools in rural areas are
female, which further discourages the enrolment of the girl child.
The challenge, therefore, is to provide quality education to large masses under
the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009. This goal is yet to
be realized fully, as nearly 28 per cent of the children in the age group of 6 11 years and
32 per cent in the age group of 11 14 years are still out of school.
Literacy among Youth
The future progress of any society depends on the quality of its youth population. The
proportion of literates among youth in India has considerably improved over the years
and reached 88.2 per cent in 2009 10. The percentage, however, is lower among STs and
SCs with 80.46 per cent this often discourages SC ST parents from sending their
children for higher education by foregoing their current income. This general apathy
has also been noticed among Muslim parents and students. The development paradigm
thus needs to outline strategies for the creation of productive decent employment while
ensuring the larger participation of marginalized groups.
Gender Parity
While the SCs and STs are very close to others in attaining gender parity in terms of net
attendance in primary education, the issue still remains worrisome at the secondary
level of education. Among SCs, there are 711 girls per 1000 boys attending secondary
education, with this figure being higher than that for STs at 623 and very close to the
national average of 732. In the sphere of tertiary education, the gender parity is very
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
27
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
close with 964 girls per 1000 boys attending. More interestingly, the ratio of SC girls
enrolled in higher education is higher than that of boys at 1114 girls per 1000 boys. This
could be partly attributed to the scholarship scheme of the government. In the case of
STs, however, the ratio is the lowest at 623. This could be because for them the distance
to the education facility from their places of residence poses a major hindrance, which
discourages girls from continuing their higher education. Thus, the major concern for
the new development paradigm is he needs to universalize secondary education and
improve its quality in order to ensure gender parity.
Infant Mortality
With an infant mortality rate (IMR) of 47 per 1000 live births in 2010, India is unlikely to
attain its target of 26.7 by 2015, despite achieving a significant improvement in the IMR
over the period 2000 10. The high IMR among SCs and STs is generally attributed to
various factors including their poverty, high incidence of malnutrition, lack of health
facilities in the SC ST-dominated areas and poor public health service delivery.
Moreover, the available evidence suggests the persistence of discrimination in the
delivery of nutrition support services to the marginalized groups.
Child Immunization
With 74 per cent of the children in the age group of 12 23 months in 2009 having been
immunized against measles, India has made remarkable progress in the area of child
immunization. However, the country is still likely to miss the MDG target of 100 per
cent immunization by 2015 the ratio was less than the national average by 4 percentage
points. There is also a huge inter-state variability, with less than one-third of the
children having been vaccinated in Orissa as compared to 70 per cent in Uttarakhand
during 2011.
Use of Telephony
There has been a rapid increase in the use of mobiles and landline telephones in India.
About 63.2 per cent of households in India were seen to own mobile telephone in 2011.
The percentage of access to telephones is the lowest at 34.8 for STs,
Access to Safe Drinking Water and Sanitation
Access to safe drinking water is crucial as it prevents water-borne diseases and
consequently high morbidity. While there has been a considerable improvement in
access to safe drinking water, still over one-third of the ST households and nearly onefourth of the SC and Other households do not have such access as per the 2011
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
28
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Population Census. Thus, the situation of STs with regard to this indicator is far worse
than the national average. There is also evidence of discriminatory access to safe
drinking water for SCs, particularly in the rural areas, as they may be allowed to fetch
water only after the Other caste households have enjoyed their turn.46 The location of
such facilities in upper caste localities also affects the overall access to such facilities by
the SC households.47
What are the different policies made by govt. on education and employment to
empower tribal’s?
Policy issues on Education of tribal
National Policy of Education (1986 and revised Policy in 1992) suggested the following
programmes for education of tribal people.
1) Opening primary schools in Tribal Areas
2) Need to develop curricula of their language
3) Promoting schedule tribes youth to work as teachers
4) Ashram schools, Residential schools should be established in large scale in Tribal
areas.
5) Incentives to encourage their life style through education.
Policy Initiatives for Generating Employment for Young People
The concerns of young people have always been at the centre of India s policy
formation. The Planning Commission of the GOI has stated that the recognition of
youth is vital for the community. However, youth unemployment has not received the
necessary attention Visaria
. India s first National Youth Policy, formulated in
1988, recognised that the most important component of a youth programme has to be
the elimination of unemployment. Considering the limited achievement of the objective
of the 1988 Youth Policy, a new National Youth Policy was announced in 2003 that was
aimed at»galvanizing young people to rise up to new challenges«. The 2005 National
Council for Skill Development (NCSD) targeted skills development as a major national
policy. The GOI, through planned investment in skills development, hopes to realise a
demographic dividend.
Right to Work
The Constitution of India, under Article 41, provides that »the State shall within the
limits of its economic capacity and development, make effective provision for securing
the right to work, to education and to public assistance in cases of unemployment, old
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
29
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
age, sickness and disablement, and in other cases of undeserved want«. Article 38 states
that the state shall strive to promote the welfare of the people; Article 43 states it shall
endeavor to secure a living wage and a decent standard of living to all workers. These
promises are part of the Directive Principles of state policy of the Constitution of India.
Employment Exchange
The Employment Exchange organization, operated by the Federal Ministry of Labour,
runs more than 900 individual employment exchanges in order to better match demand
and supply with regard to work opportunities. Job seekers register with these
employment exchanges and are notified as soon as any vacancy in the government
sector matches their profile. According to the Employment Exchanges (Compulsory
Notification of Vacancies) Act of 1959, in any State or area thereof, the employer in
every establishment in the public sector in that State or area shall
vacancy in any employment in that establishment
before filling any
notify that vacancy to such
employment exchanges as may be prescribed. Employment exchanges play a significant
role in assisting young people in finding employment. They also assist them in starting
self-employment ventures through vocational guidance activities. Registering the
applications of job seekers and notifying them about vacancies, collection and
dissemination of employment market information, vocational guidance for students
and young people are the major functions of employment exchanges.
Vocational Training
India needs to train 70 million people in vocational skills over the next five years. In
addition, there is a need to retrain another 6 million workers. The government s
target is to train 500 million people by 2022, also by encouraging the participation of
entrepreneurs and private organizations. The target is high. The workability of the
structure that India has developed would depend on the capacity of the people who are
responsible for reaching the objectives. Efforts over the past few years have not yielded
satisfactory results with regard to the achievement of the objective in a defined period.
Against the background of a huge gap between skills demand and supply, India has
taken the initiative to develop a system of vocational training. Under the system, young
people are provided with skills-related training. The Directorate General of
Employment and Training under the Ministry of Labour of the GOI formulates policies,
laying down norms and standards and conducting trade tests and certification of
vocational training under the aegis of the training advisory body, the National Council
of Vocational Training. The main objective of the scheme is to provide employable skills
to school leavers, existing workers and IT graduates. Youth employability must be
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
30
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
increased through skill development and vocational training. The GOI has realised the
importance of skills. A Coordinated Action Plan for skill development has been
approved by the Cabinet to have a target of 500 million skilled persons by 2022. »A
three-tier institutional structure consisting of: i the Prime Minister s National Council
on Skill Development, (ii) the National Skill Development Coordination Board and (iii)
the National Skill Development Corporation, has been set up to take forward the Skill
Development Mission (GOI 2010: 205).This is an important initiative (S. Manhendra
Dev 2011).
Employment Generation Programmes
In recent years, Employment Generation Programmes (EGP) have emerged as an
important employment policy tool, particularly in developing countries such as India.
This policy package includes a wide range of activities intended to increase labour
demand (for example, direct job creation); to increase the quality of labour supply
(training and retraining); or to improve the matching of workers and jobs (job search
assistance). Significant economic and social benefits are expected to accrue from these
measures. More recently, the case for EGPs has also emphasised the potential social
benefits in the form of inclusion and participation that comes from productive
employment. EGPs can serve equity objectives as well, most obviously, when
programmes are targeted at vulnerable and disadvantaged groups. The major
programmes that are currently in operation in India are: Mahatma Gandhi National
Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), Swarnajayanti Gram Swarozgar
Yojana SGSY , Swarna Jayanti Shahari Rozgar Yojana SJSRY and the Prime Minister s
Employment Generation Programme (PMEGP). The MNREGA provides for 100 days of
unskilled manual labour per year on public works projects for any rural household
member who wants such work at the stipulated minimum wage rate. The aim is to
dramatically reduce poverty by providing extra earnings for poor families, as well as
empowerment and insurance. If the programme had worked the way it was designed
to, then anyone who wanted work would get it. However, an analysis of data from
India s National Sample Survey for
2010 reveals considerable unmet demand for
work in all States. The extent of the unmet demand is greater in the poorest States
ironically, where the scheme is needed most. Labour-market responses to the scheme
are weak. The scheme is attracting poor women into the workforce, although the locallevel rationing processes favour men.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
31
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
What are the emerging factors for unemployment of tribal people in India?
Reasons for Youth Unemployment
The economic survey in 2012 stresses that in order to achieve inclusive growth, India
must create adequate employment opportunities: the number of unemployed is large
and there are more youth entering the job market. In the absence of detailed data on
youth and employment, it is very difficult to pinpoint factors that impede the
availability of employment opportunities for them. However, as in other countries,
unemployment among young people in India is the highest compared to other age
groups. The reasons include:
Shortage of Jobs
Agriculture has been the dominant sector of labour concentration. Since 1991, the shares
of the manufacturing and service sectors have grown faster with regard to GDP and
much slower with regard to employment, as working methods became more capitalintensive. According to various estimates, productivity during the period from 2004 to
grew
per cent. India s economic growth was thus more due to productivity than
employment.
`
In the wake of the limited creation of additional jobs, workers
especially youth
found themselves without jobs. The prevailing situation forced them either to opt for
unskilled or casual work in the informal sector or to enroll for further studies. Many
who could not afford to go for further education opted for self-employment with
extremely low returns. The large number of self-employed or, for that matter, casual
workers is an instance of self-exploitation since such workers are without any effective
protection.
Employability
In order to take full advantage of the »demographic dividend«, it is imperative for India
to transform its labour force into an asset. As of now, only 5 per cent of the work force
has undergone any kind of vocational training, but even many of those are not
employable, since the skills acquired have limited market application (Chandrasekhar
et al. 2006).
Furthermore, India s education system is primarily of a generalist nature and is
not connected to the labour market. According to NASSCOM,2 almost 40 per cent of the
skilled workforce is not employable because the acquired education and training are of
substandard quality. The GOI recently initiated major work in skills up-grading.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
32
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Skills Mismatch
India is generally seen as a labour surplus economy with a majority of workers having
limited or negligible marketable skills. Furthermore, on examining the situation more
closely one finds that India has a lopsided skills stock. On the one hand, a large section
of the workforce are not able to get even minimum wages, as made mandatory by the
government; on the other hand, there are a few people with marketable skills who are
able to demand higher rewards. Recently, there has been increased activity in the
acquiring of skills. Young people are attending various technical institutes in large
numbers. This can be seen in the information and communication technology sector,
which has experienced a huge inflow of IT-skilled workers. In addition, it has caused
problems due to the unregulated growth of technical institutions in the private sector
and a lack of guidance for youth in choosing areas of training. As a result, an imbalance
in the Indian labour market has created a surplus in some skills and shortages in others.
Women – Security and Social Restrictions
The opening up of the Indian economy has created increased employment
opportunities for female workers, particularly in IT, retail, travel and tourism. Their full
engagement, however, remains restricted due to problems of personal security, biased
attitudes of co-workers and social customs. Faced with ineffective protection, young
female workers either select jobs for security considerations or prolong their education.
Various studies have indicated marriage as a major cause of women workers
withdrawing from the labour market.
Decent Work Deficit
India has some of the most developed labour legislation granting comprehensive
protection to its workforce. The enforcement of these laws is, however, lacking,
resulting in unabated exploitation, especially of those employed in the informal sector.
In addition, most of the new jobs are created in private
small and medium-sized
enterprises. Consequently, young workers are deprived of rights that are guaranteed
under the Indian Constitution, national/state laws and international conventions. The
worst affected are contract and casual workers, who, despite undertaking identical
work, are confronted with inhumane employment conditions, including long hours,
lower wages, no social security and no right to organize. The absence of a formal social
security system also gets in the way of securing effective enforcement of labour laws
and rights, including trade unions.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
33
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Challenges with regard to Tribal Youth Employment
In an environment of ever-increasing costs of living and non-existent social protection, a
young worker is condemned to fend for him- or herself and also to provide for
dependents. In desperation, they accept any job with any conditions that are offered to
them. Most of these jobs are without any rights. They are made to work for longer
hours, paid much less and can be terminated without any notice. As a result, India is
faced with increasing numbers of working poor. The other challenge that young people
are facing is insecurity at the workplace. Regular and continuous forms of employment
have been replaced with non-permanent job contracts that involve a specific project or
activity for a defined period of time. In the process, workers not only lack employmentrelated benefits but also the capacity to plan their own life. As already mentioned, the
majority of young people have either limited or no skills. Furthermore, the existing
education system does not equip them for employment as it is far from meeting market
needs. The avenues of good education and training are few and extremely expensive.
Technical institutions in the private sector have been drawing undue benefits
from the imbalance by exploiting young people and their parents. Finally, the flow of
information on the availability of training and/or job opportunities is tardy. There is
inefficiency in the working of employment exchange, primarily due to the negligible
attention paid to updating and sharing information. The functioning of Industrial
Training Institutes has also been repeatedly questioned as they have been imparting
training that has no market.
As a result, young people in India face an environment that is not rendering the
desired support. It provides neither affordable opportunities to acquire and/or upgrade
skills nor sufficient information on suitable employment opportunities. In the absence
of such support and any form of social security, young people, in desperation, accept
exploitative employment conditions.
Way Forward
The challenge of improving the employability of youth and their accessing decent jobs
requires improvement in quality of education, job training, up gradation of skills, and
interface between industry, policy makers and training institutions. However, this also
requires creation of adequate decent jobs in the non-farm sector 12th mainly
manufacturing as is envisaged in the 12 Plan. In the Indian context, to make the youth
employable, the government of India is laying emphasis on skill development and has
set a target of skilling 500 million by 2022 and 50 million in the 12th plan. To achieve
this target, National Policy on Skill Development focuses on improving quality,
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
34
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
quantity, access and outreach of training. Different innovative measures have been
followed to reach the difficult areas. Some of the good examples are in terms of virtual
classrooms, mobile vans, simulation based etc. There are 23 Central Ministries, which
are engaged in skill development. In order to recognize the prior learning, workers are
tested and given certificates of trained manpower. There are general programmes,
group-specific and region specific, for enhancing the employability of the youth.
The National Skill Development Agency has been mandated to monitor the
progress of skilling in the country, operationalize the National Skill Qualification
Framework, which facilitates both horizontal and vertical mobility and makes skill
aspirational among the prospective trainees. To incentivize the students and help the
disadvantaged, the government has started Standard Training & Assessment Reward
(STAR)
Scheme, wherein the passed trainee is provided an incentive of Rs 10,000.
Besides this, students are provided scholarship and other facilities, particularly in the
remote areas. Further, through sector skill councils an attempt is made to link training
with the industry requirement.
The Government is also working to expand access to education and vocational
training for workers in the country side, including rural broadband networks to connect
remote areas with educational opportunities as also using Common Service Centres at
the Panchayat level for training. The role of advocacy to promote awareness among the
youth about various plan schemes / vocational institutions needs to be initiated. In
addition, there is an urgent need to speed up the setting up of the Sector Skills Councils
and putting in place the National Occupational Standards to make National Skill
Qualification System operational. This would facilitate modification of curriculum in
tune with the industry's requirement.
At present, there is no organized and scientific system in place to provide labour
market information in terms of supply-demand position in the labour market to guide
the labour and training policies, training providers, prospective labour force and the
employers. There is an urgent need to put in place the same. To make manufacturing an
engine of growth and to generate employment opportunities, the government has
announced new policies as part of the 12th Five year Plan, aiming to create 100 million
work opportunities by 2022, mainly in labour intensive manufacturing sectors such as
textiles, gems & jewelry, and leather industry. For those who are engaged in selfemployment, hand holding in terms of credit availability as also market and technical
assistance is provided in the industrial policy and the 12th Plan focuses on strengthening
this further. To conclude, there should be an integrated policy focus in the coming years
on promoting growth that supports livelihood.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
35
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Findings
KISS as a role model for tribal people in special reference to their education and
unemployment
Measure To Be Taken For Prosperity of Schedule Tribes
Many programmes helped tribal to improve their conditions. The following are
important for further improvement.
1. Strict implementation of reservation of seats in public sector employment
2. Proper looking into reservation of seats in institutions of higher learnings.
3. Formulation of proper welfare schemes for prosperity of Tribals based on fact
data.
4. In private sector also these should be reservations for schedule tribes.
5. The present 7.5% of reservation for government services should be increased
whenever necessary.
6. Destroy of their habitations should be reduced because, major projects, SEZs and
other projects are causing for migration of ST s
7. Their habitation (Thandas) should be converted into gram panchayaths.
8. Development of forest villages is needed for Tribal prosperity
9. Empowering Tribals in governance is the most needed one.
10. During every plan review and revision is must to alter policies.
11. Stopping of corruption and ineffective work progress in the implementation of
schemes be-longing to schedule Tribes.
Creation of Productive Employment Opportunities for SCs and STs
Access to productive and decent employment is the most important source of income
security, and reduction in poverty and inequality. Much of the success of poverty
reduction strategies would depend on the type of employment opportunities being
generated for the poor and marginalized social groups. Since most of the SCs and STs
are working as casual wage labourers or as self-employed workers in low-paying
occupations under poor working conditions, discrimination in hiring practices and
wage payments add to their woes. It is imperative for the proposed policies to break
this vicious circle of poverty and low earning levels. The existing policies also need to
be evaluated to determine their success in improving employment and income
generation for the marginalized groups.
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
36
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
Absolute Reduction in Poverty
Since poverty is multidimensional in nature, multi-pronged measures need to be
implemented and intensified for poverty eradication. The development strategy,
therefore, has to create productive employment opportunities while enabling the SCs
and STs, including women belonging to these communities, to avail of such
opportunities. The enabling process involves their increased access to quality education
at the secondary and tertiary levels, particularly in job-oriented vocational and technical
education programs. The increasing healthcare costs of the poor and the marginalized,
and their impoverishments need to be reversed by providing them non-discriminatory
access to quality healthcare facilities free of cost.
Development of Equity Weighing Indicators
National averages have an inherent capacity to conceal inequalities. The huge
disparities in various indicators for SCs and STs testify this fact. It has been seen how
the current value of the national averages changes by 8 to 17 percentage points after
weighing group inequalities.55 It would be useful to measure the progress in
development by weighing various types of inequities by giving the highest weights to
those in the lowest quintiles or income groups and vice versa. Alternatively, separate
targets can be set for ensuring progress among the poorest or amongst social groups
such as the SCs and STs at the lowest levels of development, which are then measured
and reported separately to ensure that they benefit from the overall progress. The MDG
target of promoting girls education provides an example of such a precedent for
adoption of this approach.
Governance, Institutions, Accountability and Effectiveness
The post-2015 development paradigm should be based on sound participatory and
effective governance principles. It must ensure that the institutions which have been
created for governance effectively reach out to the most marginalized and deprived
population groups, and urgently act upon their voices and concerns.
The rise in inequalities among various social groups is also the result of a
number of extraneous factors such as the withdrawal of the State from public services,
inadequate provision, deteriorating quality of service delivery, and its pro-market
policies favouring a tiny section of well-off people. The weakening of public institutions
catering to education, healthcare and basic amenities under the new liberalized model
of development is forcing the poor to depend on private services that have no social
protection component. These developments thus prevent many people belonging to the
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
37
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
marginalized communities from seeking the concerned service, as a sizeable proportion
of them have been pushed into poverty while availing of such unaffordable services.
Proper Planning and Monitoring
The commitments of governments to take various initiatives for meeting the MDGs in a
time-bound framework have made them accountable to multilateral donor agencies,
civil society organizations (CSOs), and citizens of the country. The CSOs have been
encouraged by this development, which has led to their launching of intensified
movements demanding the development of marginalized and vulnerable population
groups within a rights framework as enshrined in the Indian Constitution. The
enactment of NREGA, the RTI Act, RTE, Right to Food, Right to Health (in making) and
the use of social audits to evaluate the Government s programs are largely attributed to
the relentless efforts of CSOs and a favourable judiciary in the country that have
successfully mainstreamed the demand for the dignified development of the citizens of
India.
Improving Data and Information Base
The availability of data and its periodicity is critical for facilitating informed policy
planning, assessment, advocacy and public debate. Rising group inequalities have led
to a growing demand for group-specific development interventions. The lack of such
information is seriously jeopardizing group-specific policy planning and interventions.
Although the Government of India has a comprehensive statistical system spread across
the country, it suffers from serious information gaps on various social, economic,
political and cultural issues of development targeted at different social and religious
groups as also at regional levels. Information on the issues of exclusion and
discrimination do not feature in any official surveys. Moreover, the small sample size
makes it rather impossible to use information for district level planning. There is also a
significant data gap with regard to the nomadic and denotified tribal populations. All
this has led to an increasing demand for group-specific policy interventions, which are
generally hampered due to the lack of comprehensive statistics.
Conclusion
We live in an increasingly interdependent world. There is growing awareness of this
following the global financial crisis from 2008 on. The ever-increasing size of the youth
workforce, both skilled and unskilled, in an environment of job scarcity means more
young people are faced with limited employment opportunities, causing them to be
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
38
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
either underemployed or unemployed. Indian youth, in the absence of any formal social
security, is thus faced with the challenge of survival and limited growth prospects. To
check unemployment among the tribal youth in India, various measures have been
initiated. India has introduced a number of employment-generating schemes, including
those under MNREGA. Similar policy initiatives have been taken for skilled workers.
India has created measures to impart skills as part of a major effort and is receiving
assistance from various countries, including Germany, with regard to vocational
training. However, these initiatives have had limited impact. There is a need to learn
about others experiences, their employment guarantee programmes and also their
social security programmes. In an increasingly integrated world where the causes of
unemployment are of a global nature, national measures may prove insufficient in
overcoming the challenges. There is a need for a global understanding of youth
unemployment. Global organisations need to put special emphasis on the problem of
youth unemployment to enhance employability and employment opportunities.
The directive principles of Indian constitution referred the development of
Schedule Tribes in the society. Though policies are vast implementation is not proper so
both state and central gout have to take proper steps. Since 1951 governments are
implementing number of programmes and schemes for the development of Schedule
Tribes. But the implementation is not effective. Besides this, lack of awareness about the
programmes is also strong factor due to illiteracy among tribes. Therefore, there is need
for extension of contribution from government side and other voluntary organizations
and likeminded NGOs for effective implementation of programmes and bringing
awareness among Tribes. Then only the future of the Schedule Tribes will be in good
prosperity.
References
1. Chandrasekhar, C. P., J. Ghosh and A. Roychowdhury (2006) The Demographic
Dividend and Young India s Economic Future, Economic and Political Weekly, 9
December, pp. 5055 5064.
2. Bhai, P.N. (1986). Harijan Women in Independent India. New Delhi: B.R.
Publishing
3. Dev, S. Mahendrav and M. Venkatanarayana (2011) Youth Employment and
Unemployment in India, Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research,
Mumbai, April. Available at: http://www.igidr.ac.in/pdf/publication/WP-2011009.pdf
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
39
Rasmi Ranjan Puhan
IMPACT OF UNEMPLOYMENT AND EDUCATION ON TRIBAL FAMILIES AND YOUTH - POLICIES AND
ISSUES ON INDIAN GOVERNMENT
4. Ghandially, R. (1988). Introduction. In: R. Ghandially (ed.), Women in Indian
Society, New Delhi: Sage Publication, pp. 13-19.
5. Ghandially, R. & P. Kumar (1988). Bride burning: The psycho-social dynamics of
dowry deaths. In: R. Ghandially (ed.), Women in Indian Society, pp. 167-177.
6. Hittleman, D. R. And Simon, A. J. (1997), Interpreting Educational Research: An
Introduction for Consumers of Research, Prentice-Hall, Inc. New Jersey.
7. Kumar, K. (1988). Education: Safer options. In: Bouton and Oldenburg (eds.),
India Briefing: 1988, pp. 111-128.
8. Mitra, A. (1979). The Status of Women, Literacy and Employment. New Delhi:
Indian Council of Social Science Research.
9. Planning Commission (2008) Eleventh Five Year Plan, 2007 2012. Vol. 1,
Inclusive Growth. New Delhi: Planning Commission, Government of India.
10.
(2011) Economic Survey 2010 2011, Department of Economic Affairs,
Ministry of Finance. New Delhi: Government of India.
11.
(2012) Economic Survey 2011 2012, Department of Economic Affairs,
Ministry of Finance. New Delhi: Government of India.
12. S. Sanghi and A. Srija (2014): Youth unemployment in India, planning
commission govt. of India, New Delhi. Page no-1 and 2.
13. UNESCO (2005), Quantitative Research Methods in Educational Planning,
UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning, Paris, France.
14. Visaria, P. (1998) Unemployment among Youth in India: Level, Nature and
Policy Implications. Employment and Training Paper 36, Employment and
Training Department. Geneva: International Labour Organisation.
15. World Bank
India s Employment Challenge
Creating Jobs, Helping
Workers. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Creative Commons licensing terms
Author(s) will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Social Sciences Studies
shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflicts of interest, copyright violations and
inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated into the research work. All the published works are meeting the Open Access
Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and non-commercial purposes
under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Social Sciences Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
40