European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies
ISSN: 2501 - 9988
ISSN-L: 2501 - 9988
Available on-line at: http://www.oapub.org/soc
10.5281/zenodo.58996
Volume 1│Issue 1│2016
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON
MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
Abdel Mahdi al Masri
Department of Business Administration, Nahda University, Egypt
email: abdelmasri@zoho.com
Abstract:
The article investigates the contemporary economic tendencies that marketing is a new
perspective for health management, offering greater and broader view of the progress
made to date by different sciences and disciplines. Appropriating marketing as a
management tool means to have a broader instrumental to work according to carry the
drugs market, medical technology and instrumentation, offer and reorient services,
design and implement health programs, reconciling the objectives and purposes of the
health institution with the user, consumer and patient, thus, both achieve their ends. If
we are applying appropriate marketing techniques, surely, we will find an ally to
produce well-being, to respond to the new paradigms that become ineluctable
challenges of everyone, anywhere in the world, we advocate the health of mankind.
Keywords: management, marketing of health services, health economics, health
promotion
Introduction
Peter Drunker, considers that "effective people are not oriented towards the problems, but to
opportunities, feed opportunities and let them die of inertia to the problems." Based on the
above postulate, I think that for health managers, in any context and latitude, marketing
is an "opportunity" for both feeding opportunities and a management tool for
troubleshooting, hence it is appropriate for us travel by theory and reach practical
application, how marketing becomes a necessary ally to respond to new paradigms of
health in modern times. The more we appropriate knowledge; reality can be interpreted
in more varied forms. When we apply the knowledge to explain and understand the
reality, we are improving reality and enriching knowledge, as long as the scientific
method and objective approach prevail in what we do. For such reasons, marketing is a
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved
Published by Open Access Publishing Group ©2015.
45
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
science that allows responding to new paradigms of health and opportunity, to find
solutions to the problems faced today, to lead people and society to wellness.
Marketing began in the so-called commercial marketing, in the first half of the
last century and with the passing of time became evident their ability to use the services
field and then to the ideas. Today, it is inconceivable the launch of a new product
without marketing program, which was based on market research study of consumers,
proper selection of strategies using a marketing mix that allows to reach the target
market and positioner the product. The launch of a service is also preceded by a similar
process, mainly in those where impacts more globalization and demands that are highly
competitive. The social marketing is also a common practice to counter aggressive
strategies of commercial advertising to promote consumption of harmful to health
products, others to advocate social causes of public good. Also, the corporate image of
institutions is made, while considering the marketing policy that increasingly thrives on
highly sophisticated techniques to sell their ideas and projects.
The business marketing, which includes everything related to products and
services, has a good representation in present. Corporate marketing is a science that
requires creating a philosophy of action of managers, to drive the production of goods
and services to the satisfaction of the needs, desires and demands of consumers. Social
marketing, you have to satisfy the consumer requirements, maintain a transparent and
balanced market that allows you to choose rationally and consciously best suited to
their needs goods and services. The new era requires therefore different attributes in
human resources in general and particularly managers; it requires a different mental
attitude, creative, innovative and globalizing capacity. The current manager has to
think marketing approach, thinking about product concepts for what they are and the
benefits they provide, on competitiveness by product quality and services, management
of prices in specific markets for specific audiences, with a flexibility that allows them
to survive in such a dynamically changing environment.
Health and its concept, which has also come a long way, is moving towards new
paradigms that require different views with regard to the goods and services, to
respond to new needs and transformation in the way of thinking and acting of the
contemporary consumers. Regarding the most recent health policies, we ca remark that
within the current demands and standards raised on the agenda worldwide, health
promotion probably must be the most innovative, comprehensive and possible, being
both the most difficult and costly to implement. Five lines in the strategy outlined in the
Ottawa Charter characterize it:
a) formulation of healthy public policy;
b) creating supportive environments;
c) strengthening community action;
d) developing personal skills, and
e) reorienting health services
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
46
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
All these guidelines, involve a profound change in the individual, the community and
the institutional environment. Therefore, to achieve this, it is necessary to apply
diversified approaches in order to change strategies, so that social marketing becomes
an ideal tool to achieve these purposes. The above approach is reinforced, considering
the three parallel lines of action involving health promotion:
a) promoting healthy lifestyles;
b) enabling people to increase their capacity to control the delivery of beneficial
health services, and
c) implementing structural conditions that make possible the full and effective
health for the entire population.
Assimilating new paradigms, also it requires the participation of new disciplines
of science which converges: social marketing, coupled with social mobilization,
communication and involve the community through participation, to achieve change in
terms of the traditional patterns to see related health cure of the disease. It is only
possible to face the paradigm of health seen as a challenge to reduce inequities, as
expressed in the goal of "health for all", expand the scope of prevention, and helping
people to confront their circumstances, to encourage social participation, strengthen
community services, health and promote healthy public policies.
Hiroshi Nakajima said in 1988, that "…health is a product of social action and not
merely a result of medical care . Focusing on health with this new paradigm requires
undoubtedly confront with the support of the social sciences, based on the development
of medical science and the technological advancement. The preventable deaths, both
individual responsibility and public health care, justify the effort to educate, inform,
persuade, train, change the environment and improving the conditions in which man
lives, so you can get a higher quality and thus being. Only in this way we can bridge the
gap between policy and reality and respond to the claim of equity and access to health
services as quality health services you have to come after people gain access him and
that is why it is one of the most sensitive issues on the agenda of international
organizations that advocate the right to life of the planet.
Some countries, for more than 35 years ago they gave solution related to access
to health and discrimination, highlighting how from this principle of equity can exhibit
indicators similar to those of developed countries health. Even in difficult economic
conditions, the presence of family doctors, as a key link in the Primary Care Systems
Emergency and rapid response of the health service to all epidemiological situations so
requires, ensure the health of the population. Without the issue of quality in the service
offered, remains a major point of reflection and analysis, to meet the needs of the
population and reorienting health services based on meeting them. Thus, corporate
marketing applied to services, facilitates work in terms of improving health and wellbeing. Because of its positive contribution to constantly improve the performance of
health services, marketing, in all its possible applications, it makes it a powerful ally of
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
47
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
the health manager, by helping him to respond to the challenges posed by current
health policies in the light of new paradigms. Apply marketing to public health, it is an
imperative of our time, in a context of contra-marketing that recommend to avoid
practices and products that are harmful to health, such as alcohol, snuff, drugs and
programs and campaigns to bring rational limits products consumption products, such
as fat, salt, artificial foods and GM, as well as prevent sexually transmitted diseases and
AIDS.
Among others, the application spectrum of marketing to health activity is not
limited to its potential in promoting health and promoting healthy lifestyles, it covers
the quality of health services, the rational use of drugs and the approach and
contribution to solving the various public health problems that are generated as a result
of inequality. The high competitiveness leading globalization requires marketing as a
tool to guide development toward wellness, towards ethical consumption and
sustainable development. It is a working tool that should be considered in the change in
the physician relationships patient, where an increasing maturity and autonomy that is
reaching the patient, derived among others, the actual development of work health
promotion and raising the health culture, which favors a new dimension in the
relationship is more remarkable health culture, which favors a new dimension in the
relationship where the health professional has to accomplish the transaction through
negotiation and not from the hegemonic position previously occupied. An interesting
element that we must consider is the fact that the Internet can act in this relationship
both in a role of ally as opposition, increasing the role of patients, users of health
services, demanding drugs and technologies for the health professional or the system
itself cannot be answered or actually does not constitute an important element or even
effect is not yet proven. Although the mindset of managers, officials and health
professionals in general, always intended to provide the highest quality service and
promote healthy behaviors is present, it is not unusual to find that they have the
theoretical elements and instruments of marketing to address it.
Actually in that so- called "new management model of health services", the approach
to the consumer and considers the worker health as the internal customer, who has to
be satisfied to produce satisfaction external customers. Hence, the importance of that
communication flows in both directions, the structures flatten and epidemiological
information enables to respond to the present and foresee the future, so that health
services can respond to the interests of consumers and the requirements public
health. marketing is a tool based health management, while enabling detect and
respond to the health needs from research, evaluation and analysis of health demand,
patient satisfaction and make this identification to anticipate and meet both
requirements. It is therefore a useful tool for organizational change based on the full
implementation of health objectives in the light of the paradigms that currently support
health policies.
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
48
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
Functions and potentials
Marketing is considered a "…comprehensive process, seen from the final results, from the
point of view of the consumer a "business philosophy and mental attitude", "a generation of
guidelines to select and develop appropriate products and services essential activity life,
promoting and distributing them so they get the maximum benefit for the capital employed. "
Analyzed in this way, it can be considered also as …the strategy that allows reconciling
the objectives and motivations that come to market the consumer and the producer or supplier of
goods and services .
The market is the place where consumer and producer or supplier are, the
consumer intends to acquire goods and services to meet needs based on their
acquisitive possibilities, while producer and supplier offering goods and services to be
profitable, profit that allows them to continue the production of goods and
services. This approach is valid for both profit and nonprofit, obviously in the case of
non-profit, entities profitability is the basis of sustaining these institutions and make
progress towards improving its management. From this premise functions detach the
marketing and marketing applied to health, the first and essential social dimension,
aimed at improving the quality of life with an ethical approach and supported in
promoting health, early detection and timely, appropriate and effective treatment. At
the same time, this does not relieve the economic dimension aimed at achieving
profitability and rational use of resources in terms of achieving the objectives. Its
potential is evident when it is measured as the application of marketing possible
to improve the use of resources, build and deploy new services and programs based on
the needs and motivate and engage workers and regulate demand from adequate
production of services and products required, attracting resources in terms of
improving the health and quality of life and improve the image of health institutions,
among others.
Paradoxes and Controversies
One of the most debated issues regarding marketing and its application to the field of
health, is conceived as concerning the commodification of health and when it comes to
social marketing to individual freedom. Both arguments put marketing and use by
health professionals in an ethical plane, when really what it is is to use an appropriate
tool for health management. Other arguments are aimed to consider that no use is
necessary and they are very limited the possibilities offered in relation to health, when
in fact what it does is open a much wider to face reality spectrum. in our view,
controversies and paradoxes, are lack of knowledge and in other cases, arguments are
nothing more than the reaction of the critics of social causes and those who are
responsible for handling and misleading advertising, trying to curb social change
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
49
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
programs regarding behaviors in general and health in particular, as they put at risk
their economic interests. Transnationals seek ways to reach consumers without
information and unprotected, to replace its markets to those that either have already
taken decisions consistent with the health and quality of life, or die product of not being
able to have the knowledge required to make a proper balance between what I should
and should not eat, or because when his health has been severely affected, income does
not allow them access to health services.
The social marketing, it is the answer to the changes required from a behavioral
point of view and is routinely used in solving problems related to health, promoting
adoption of healthy behaviors and the appropriate use of health services. The social
marketing programs educate, persuade and guide the individual and societies about
everything that affects their health.
Arguments supporting the application of marketing to health management
Management of health services does not require use marketing strategies and is not
ethical because transgresses individual freedom, promote or change ideas and behavior
of individuals, are the central points that support the arguments against the usability of
marketing in health management. We consider convenient through each of the
arguments and present our view on this, although generally already been outlined in
this paper.
When we point out the importance of applying marketing as a management tool
in health services, we are not referring to market the medicine and never have to reduce
it to private health services. We have already noted how the marketing approach is
to essential principle project and provide health services according to the needs of the
target market, that is, users and customers, patients, in order to preserve their
health. Using the concept preserve health , it implies both prevent and cure. The
marketing will be the tool that will enable the social service orientation. Public and
private are to be directed to their human content, where by managers achieve to meet
the needs, expectations and desires of external customers and internal. The concept of
internal marketing or internal marketing as possible to respond to external marketing is
a premise to have satisfied customers from getting employees are sensitized with the
philosophy of quality and commit to it. Simply that meet customer needs is the raison
d'etre of any entity and in the case of health institutions, is also achieve wellbeing. When health workers feel involved with the institution and its philosophy of
action is customer satisfaction, we have a high probability of having satisfied customers
and this will enable both the customer possible to identify the needs of health services
for reorienting them based in reality leading to improvement of health
management. Effectiveness, efficiency, quality and equity, through the rational use of
resources, must be both goals, both public and private health institution would be the
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
50
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
difference if the State or the owner responsible for ensuring that these principles
govern. It is important to make clear that the state must also be held accountable with
this principle that governs the lucrative sector. The marketing system means the
exchange between clients and health professionals meet the needs and expectations
with respect to health, to achieve the individual and social welfare is reached and to
that extent meets the objectives of the health organization. With regard to the
management of health institutions, considering them as a business, both in the public
and private sectors, involving handling business, through which the objectives of
providing the service and receiving it at any time deceive or manipulate, but the proper
orientation, diagnosis and treatment required leading to welfare, accompanied by
greater respect for the patient are met and facilitating to play their role in a new context,
precisely where health education allows its active role and involvement becomes more
useful.
The marketing is the tool that allows reconciling the objectives and motives of
the population and health institutions. Using it properly is the skill of the manager;
hence, the knowledge and skills development will enable the attainment of these
goals. This approach does not make for clear and known that it is the principle of
quality as far as health care is concerned, is deemed unnecessary to take it into
consideration and work according to optimize it. Among other things we can point out
are those concerning the culture of quality, which means not only education staff
provides service with regard to the social responsibility they have, but also on the
patient, client or user of the health service. The quality of care is a learned concept and
its users must be informed which is and what are its dimensions. We can meet a
lucrative service that has high technology and instrumental diagnosis, which is very
favorable for the quality of service offered, but discriminating when their use is
necessary is something very important. If used only for profit, it is deceiving the patient
and in addition, it is not be ethical and can be harmful or at least not beneficial to
health.
However, at the opposite extreme are how some users of health services public,
consider that if they are not subjected to diagnostic tests of this nature have not been
well served. The marketing approach is aimed at giving the customer what they really
need and when health care is the consumer orientation; translated health education is
more than ethical imperative and necessary. The concept of quality in health must
frame it in five key elements:
a) professional excellence;
b) efficient use of resources;
c) minimal risk for the patient;
d) high degree of satisfaction, and
e) the final impact on health.
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
51
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
The quality of health services cannot be reduced to one or some of these
elements, as necessarily involves the integration of all these elements of a technical
nature and process them, objective and subjective, in order to achieve user satisfaction
and efficiency of the health institution. As we have seen, the management of health
services does require use marketing strategies, this does not mean that health for
commercial purposes and profit is seen, but on the contrary, that although concerns
private services these must be framed on ethical and socially oriented.
Place the medical institution able to provide answers to the new paradigms of
health; it is a challenge for health managers, first by the need to change the philosophy
of action, the form of individual, community and institutional thinking. As we have
analyzed, social marketing, is an instrument of great value to achieve the changes
required, to take on new paradigms and to enable different strategies for different
audiences.
Marketing is a philosophy of action and orientation of the health organization to
the consumer, client or patient involving the achievement of maximum awareness to
reorient health services based on real needs, where the customer is an active player in
this reform, whose central purpose is reducing the distance between the manager of the
health institution and one for which the service is offered. It allows also to enhance the
corporate image, regulate demand, motivate and engage employees, satisfy users and
provide a better utilize more rationally the resources are available. Social marketing is a
strategy that launched together with the marketing services, enabling its
application. But the scope of social marketing and questioning its application focuses
primarily on the so-called anthropological quandary or dilemma of ethics, identifying
as violation of individual freedom to propitiate changes in ideas, attitudes and
behaviors that are harmful to health and which generally are associated with
unnecessary, irrational and even addictions consumption.
It is important to note that social marketing programs are aimed to form or
modify ideas and health behaviors that positively influence this. They will inform and
persuade, not manipulate or deceive. They will enable individuals to make decisions
regarding their health having knowledge of the relationship between their way of
thinking, acting, eating, and behaving, that is, their lifestyle and health. The social
responsibility of ensuring the health and welfare of the population is obviously the
health authorities and health personnel. There is an error or confusion related to
marketing in the conceptual order and is relative to consider it synonymous with
advertising, promotion and information about the idea, product or service. Limiting the
use of information and communication as instruments to achieve behavioral change
reduces the possibilities to act and get results. It is proven that changes from
educational elements are just very slow and sometimes it is not possible to obtain the
desired impact. The social marketing faces behavioral changes from the theoretical
perspective of corporate marketing, appropriating the skills developed in the field of
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
52
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
communication and technology development, information technology and social
planning. Denying this possibility is also to deny the development of social sciences and
their application possibilities. Research impact achieved with these programs and
comparison with control groups, have highlighted the possible results obtained when
the political will translated into policy combined and efforts come together in terms of
achieving the desired changes either in terms to create barriers to access or delete
them . it is not to deny the importance of communication programs change ideas,
attitudes and behaviors, but to see them integrated into a strategy that combines the
social product to be promoted, be it an idea, practice and is accompanied or not tangible
objects, but that the costs of adoption, availability, are converging to achieve the desired
change.
Conclusion
If we reflect on the issues raised, we will find that marketing is undoubtedly a new
perspective for health management, offering a more comprehensive and breadth
approach by integrating the progress made to date by different sciences and disciplines.
Appropriating marketing as a management tool, it means to have a broader
instrumental to work according to carry the drugs market, medical technology and
instrumentation, offer and reorient services and design and implement health programs
underway, reconciling the objectives and purposes of the healthcare institution with the
user, consumer and patient, thus, both achieve their ends. let us lead by controversies
that encourage detractors is to miss an opportunity to promote health and wellness, to
fight for equality and respect citizens' rights so that humanity has a place to live right,
to be consumed what is needed and has a beneficial effect on the individual and society.
Submit to the paradoxes which put us in the difficulties is to deny the possibilities It
offers science to counter them is to see reality from a narrow and outdated prism, look
at the past and not the future, let the epidemic we approach and not have the
epidemiological thinking to analyze information to predict correctly the strategy
preventive. If we appropriate marketing, surely, we will find an ally to produce well being, to respond to the new paradigms that become ineluctable challenges of everyone,
anywhere in the world, we advocate the health of mankind.
References
1. Drucker P. The new course of management. SUMMA, April / 99 edition 59.
2. Kotler, P., Clarke, R. N., Marketing for Health Care Organizations, Englewood
Cliffs, N. J., Prentice-Hall, 1986;
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
53
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
3. P Kotler, Andreasen A. Strategic marketing for nonprofit organization. New
Jersey: Prentice Hall; 1991.
4. P. Kotler Marketing Management. Madrid: Prentice Hall; 1992.
5. Suarez Lugo N. Marketing and Health: a theoretical and
perspective. Training Centre.National School of Public Health. 1999.
practical
6. Lovelock, C., Wirtz, J., Lapert, D., Marketing des services, Pearson Education
France, Paris, 2004; 40.
7. Lovelock, C., Services Marketing, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey,
1991;
8. OPS. Report by the Director. Official Document No. 234. 1990.
9. OPS. Action Plan 1992/1995. Washington DC. OPS; 148 (HPA / HPA / 1/91).
10. Stanton, W.J. , Fundamentals of Marketing, Sixth Edition, McGraw- Hill Book
Co, New York, 1981; 81.
11. Thomas, R., Marketing Health Services, Health Administration Press, Chicago,
2004;
12. PAHO / WHO. Social Communication Manual for Health Programs. Washington
DC. PAHO 1992.
13. Andreasen AL. Marketing Social Change. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Pub 1995.
14. Vanormalingen Pineda. Quality Management in Health, Washington: PAHO /
WHO.
15. Zeithaml, V.A., Bitner, M.J., Services Marketing, Mc Graw-Hill, New York, 1996.
16. LG Shiffman, Kanut L. Lazar Consumer Behavior. 3ra. Madrid Ed. Prentice Hall
Hispano, 1994.
17. Manoff RK. Social Marketing: New imperative for public health. New York:
Proeger Pub 1985.
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
54
Abdel Mahdi al Masri –
CONTEMPORARY TENDENCIES ON MARKETING OF HEALTH SERVICES
18. Vandercammen, M., Gauty Sinechal, M., Recherche Marketing, Outil
fondamental de marketing, Ed. De Boeck, 1999, Departament De Boeck
Universite Bruxelles.
19. Buchanan DR, Sasiragha R, Zafar H. Social Marketing: a critical appraisal. Health
Promotion Intern 1994, 9 (1): 49-57.
20. Hastings GB, J. Haywood Social Marketing: a critical response. Health Promotion
Intern 1994, 9 (1): 59-64.
21. Dubois, R., Determinants of Health and Disease, Britannica Perspectives, vol. I,
1968.
Creative Commons licensing terms
Authors will retain copyright to their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms will
be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community to
copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s).Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Management and
Marketing Studies shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflict of interests,
copyright violations and inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated on the research work. All the published works are
meeting the Open Access Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and
non-commercial purposes under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 1 │ 2016
55