European Journal of Education Studies
ISSN: 2501 - 1111
ISSN-L: 2501 - 1111
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
Volume 3 │Issue 4│2017
doi: 10.5281/zenodo.399056
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF
QUALITY EDUCATION IN PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN
WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Mildred Chepkonga
PhD Student, University of Eldoret,
P.O. Box 1125-30100 Eldoret, Kenya
Abstract:
The quality of learning environment in classroom setting is critical to effective teaching
and learning process in classroom. This research paper presents the results of study
conducted in West Pokot County public Early Childhood Development Education
centres with regard to classroom environmental setting and provision of quality
education. The study involved use of qualitative and quantitative research
methodology. The target population for the research involved 365 head teachers, 682
teachers and 4 DICECE officers. Data for the research was collected through use of
questionnaire, interview and researcher observation. Data collected was analysed using
descriptive and inferential statistics for quantitative data and thematic content analysis
for qualitative data. Research results showed that 37.1% of ECDE centres studied were
not having standardised environmental setting that could facilitate provision of quality
education to pupils in West Pokot County. It was found out that less than 50% of
classrooms were ventilated, only 24.9% of classrooms studied were found to have
enough space for easy classroom movement and 36.1% of classrooms were found to be
accessible by all learners. The study recommends that there is need for ECDE teachers
to work with head teachers to ensure that classrooms setting are safe, secure and
conducive for teaching and learning process. On the policy front, there is need for
county government to work with national government to establish appropriate
standards for ideal indoor classroom environmental setting for ECDE learners.
Keywords: indoor, classroom, setting, quality, pre-school
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved.
© 2015 – 2017 Open Access Publishing Group
344
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
1. Introduction
Education is the key to national development and there is a need to maintain every
level of education especially the pre-primary stage, because it is the bedrock upon
which all other educational levels build (Assefa, 2014; Obiweluozor, 2015). Early
Childhood Development Education (ECDE) is a common practice in most societies
(Haile, 2010; Macharia, 2012). Early Childhood Education (ECE) is important in every
nation s endeavour to meet the targets for Education For ‚ll EF‚ that are: quality
early childhood education and care, free and compulsory primary education, life skill
and training for youth, adult literacy, girls education and relevant basic education
(Muthoni, 2013). Quality education refers to how much and how well children learn
and the extent to which their education translates into a range of personal, social, and
developmental benefits (Grimo, 2008; Ngware, Oketch & Ezeh, 2011). In another view,
UNICEF (2010) observed that quality education in ECDE will be provided when pupils
are healthy, nourished, and ready to participate in learning and supported by their
parents and other community members. The report also noted that the learning
environment to support quality ECDE education should be healthy, protective, gender
sensitive, safe and with adequate instructional, infrastructural and other material
resources.
Duruji, Azuh and Oviasogie (2014) observed that the learning environment
remains an important area that should be studied and well managed to enhance
learners academic performance in schools. However, very little attention has been
given to the learning environment. According to Hannah (2013), indoor classroom
environmental setting on how a teacher organizes his/her class and control may yield
positive or negative consequences for their learners in terms of provision of quality
education. A supportive ECDE learning environment promotes the development of
children s critical thinking skills (Maxwell, Mitchell & Evans, 2008). Such learning
environment is created through interactions with indoor and outdoor activities that
offer opportunities for children to set goals and persist in following through with their
plans while acquiring new knowledge and skills through purposeful play (Ngode,
2014). Wangari (2003) noted that comparative research data needed to be collected on
the status of learning environment in ECDE centres from different areas of the country
that have got different social and demographic characteristics. This is because the
situation of early childhood development programme is worsening day by day as
majority of pre-school children in northern Kenya counties are learning in deplorable
conditions.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
345
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Provision of quality education in early childhood development education
remains a significant challenge for educators and policy makers in Kenya and West
Pokot County in particular. The Uwezo Kenya (2012) report noted that 41.31% of pupils
in class three were able to read Hadithi (story) while more than half 68.69% were not
able to read and write. It was also established that 15.04% of children aged 3-5 years
were out of school. This shows that there exist challenges in the provision of early
childhood education in the West Pokot County. The study therefore investigated the
influence of learning environment on provision of quality education in public ECDE
centres in West Pokot County.
2. Purpose of the Study
The purpose of the paper was to establish the influence of indoor classroom
environment setting on provision of quality education in public ECDE centres in West
Pokot County.
3. Literature Review
3.1 Learning Environment in Early Childhood Education and Development
Learning environment are variables that can affect students
quality education
provision in schools, including performance in examinations (Ajayi, Haastrup &
Osalusi, 2010). Learning environment which include classroom spaces planning,
administrative places planning, circulation spaces planning, spaces for conveniences
planning, general infrastructure planning, the teachers as well as the pupils themselves
are essential in teaching-learning process. The extent to which pupils learning could be
enhanced depends on their location within the school compound, the structure of their
classroom, availability of instructional facilities and accessories.
3.2 Influence of Classroom Environmental Setting on Provision of Quality Education
It is generally accepted that the richer and more pleasant pre-school environment
provides more opportunities for a child to explore, experiment, plan, and make
discussions for them, thereby enabling them to progress in their learning and
development (Assefa, 2014). Recommendations have been made for setting up an
appealing environment to promote learning and interaction between children and
teachers in schools (DeBruin-Parecki, 2008; Greenberg & Rodriguez, 2007). Research
suggests that environment be set up to provide many opportunities for learning and
movement between the different areas in the classroom to reduce distractions rate and
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
346
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
provides organization for the children s play opportunities Greenberg & Rodriguez,
2007) hence provision of quality education in ECDE.
Okudo and Omutoyole (2014) indicated that a learning environment presents
learning as a life – long enterprise and enables pupils in ECDE to establish appropriate
value system that can be their compass for self-awareness and national consciousness
Olagboye (2004) suggested that existing buildings in ECDE need to be regularly
maintained and made functional by providing proper lighting, ventilation and good
temperature condition for their effective and efficient utilization to ensure good
working condition hence provision of quality education. The physical environment of
classroom has a profound effect on individual child the group as a whole and on the
others. The physical environment includes the size of the room, the colour of the walls,
the type of flooring, the number of windows (Assefa, 2014). Classroom environment
includes organized space in the interest centers. This may include areas of art, science,
blocks, books, dramatic
play,
sensory
materials,
music,
woodworking,
and
manipulative toys and games. In addition to these, library, discovery, sand and water,
cooking and computers are components of classroom environment (Haile, 2010).
Moreover, the instructional resources and classrooms should be accessible to all
pupils regardless of disability or language difference. Learning resources and areas like
textbooks books about people from various cultures and backgrounds; plastic play food
could include items from various cultures-play rice and environment like posting
pictures of people from multiple cultures and backgrounds should reflect the diversity
of the children in the classroom (Worthington, 2008) to enable provision of quality
education. According to Mark Schroeder (2002) cited by Jepleting (2013) persons (school
management) involved in school planning and design see standardised environmental
setting as an opportunity to enhance academic out comes by creating better learning
environment, quiet, safe, comfortable and healthy environments for ECDE children in
their acquisition of necessary skills during teaching and learning. There is a growing
body of work linking educational achievement and learners performances to the quality
of air they breathe in classes. A classroom with poor ventilation creates a high chance
for the spread of air borne diseases such as tuberculosis according to the Ministry of
Public Health and Sanitation (Jepleting, 2013).
Jepleting (2013) explains that the purpose of ventilating classrooms and school
buildings, at minimum, is to remove or otherwise dilute contaminants that can build up
inside the classrooms. Such contaminants come from people breathing, from their skin,
clothes, perfumes, shampoos, deodorants, from building materials and cleaning agents,
pathogens and from a host of other agents, which in sufficient concentration, are
harmful. According to Lewinski (2015) the tables and desks should be arranged
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
347
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
properly to allow easy movements, group work, play and management of group
behaviour. The arrangements should enable children to have a clear view of each other.
For a teacher to organize the classroom, he/she should pay attention to the physical
sitting arrangement (how the tables, chairs and benches have been arranged). Further,
Lewinski (2015) stated that it is important to provide adequate and appropriate
furniture. It should be borne in mind that young children are active, curious and cannot
sit still for long periods. They are energetic and their bodies are growing fast. Therefore,
the furniture and equipment provided should be designed in such a way that they
support their healthy development, for children who are healthy perform better in
school.
Schools and classroom in particular need to be designed to the appropriate
standards. Desirable designs include having friendly and agreeable entrance areas
(doors and gates), supervised private places for learners that foster a sense of
community and with particular attention to the colour used to paint them (McGregor,
2004). ECDE centres need to have adequate spaces that pupils want to pass through to
ensure smooth movement with less or no blockades or distractions (Bunting, 2004).
Research study by Higgins, Hall, Wall, Woolner and McCaughey (2005) found out that
pupils achievement was poor dilapidated school buildings however, the research failed
to show whether improvement in school infrastructure facilities resulted to improved
pupils academic performance. this study determine the degree to which schools
building improved affected provision of quality education in public ECDE centres in
West Pokot County, Kenya since Higgins study was carried out in Newcastle, United
Kingdom
Consideration of the spaces where teachers meet and collaborate was just as
important as the design of the classroom. While there can often be a separation between
the designer and user in school design, there was a growing movement towards
involving users (pupils and teachers) during planning of teaching and learning spaces
in classes, with benefits for pupils and teachers alike making meaning around what
they want from education (McGregor, 2004). This act will spur provision of quality
education. Chepkwesis (2014) indicated that there is a volume of research that suggests
less attentive and less successful pupils are particularly affected by the classroom desks
arrangement, with their on-task behaviour increasing very significantly when seated in
rows instead of tables. Scholars argue that teachers require a good knowledge of their
pupils to implement an effective seating arrangement. Seating arrangements can be
territorial (space organized by individual desk ownership) or functional (space
organized for a specific activity) (Higgins, et al, 2005). This research determine whether
the desks arrangement influenced provision of quality education in public ECDE
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
348
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
centres in West Pokot County, Kenya to see if there is similarity with what Higgins et al
(2005) established in UK.
Classroom arrangement and desks design and location may affect provision of
quality education. Higgins et al, (2005) found out that there can often be an action zone
where an increased involvement between teacher and pupils occurs across the front
rows and down the middle rows of the classroom where as some favour a horseshoe
formation to overcome the fact that often when clustering learners, group size and
placement can be driven more by furniture and arrangement than pedagogy
(Chepkwesis, 2014). It may be that a one size fits all models or solution is not possible. It
seems that different arrangements are required for different teaching and learning
contexts. What researchers do agree upon was that it was imperative for a school to
have a clear vision in order to design facilities which can accommodate this (Stevenson,
2007; Higgin et al., 2005). Still on desks arrangement in class, Hannah (2013) noted that
when pupils first steps into a classroom room, they will make a judgment about the
type of class they are going to be taking. They will look to see how desks are arranged.
They will notice what is hanging on the walls. The way in which a teacher sets up their
class allows them to communicate with their students non-verbally. By adding various
learning centres or activity centres the learners would know that this is a classroom that
likes to do hands-on experiments. The arrangement of desks also conveys that they
would not just sit and take notes, but they would act out what ever subject they are
learning. The wall art would demonstrate to the learners that the teacher cares about
their work enough to show it off. Learners would also gain an understanding of the
social expectations of the teacher in the classroom based on how the desks are
organized. Each of these tools can be used in any classroom regardless of the content
(Grubaugh & Houston, 1990; Hannah, 2013).
ECDE children should be given the comfort they need within their learning
environment. Desks and chairs should be detached so that the sitting arrangement can
be varied to allow more interaction among and between children and the teacher (Sitati,
Mwangi, Bota and Rapongo, 2016). RoK (2003) recommends that buildings and physical
facilities for young children should meet the basic standards of space, comfort and
safety. There are many studies that examine the effect of the physical conditions of
teaching spaces (which includes seating, furnishings, spatial density, privacy, noise and
acoustics, climate and thermal control, air quality, windowless classrooms, vandalism
and play-yards, light and colour on learners engagement, attainment, attendance and
wellbeing (Higgins, et al., 2005; Earthman, 2004). Some interesting contentions about the
physical aspects of learning spaces include: temperature, heating and air quality are the
most important individual elements for learners achievement (Earthman, 2004).
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
349
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Chronic noise exposure impairs cognitive functioning, with numbers of studies finding
noise-related reading problems, deficiencies in pre-reading skills, and more general
cognitive deficits (Higgins, et al., 2005).
Schools and classrooms can be more than a place to inhabit: they can also acquire
an emotional significance. One perspective is that educators play an important role in
constructing classrooms and schools, and therefore learners identities. ‚n extension of
this idea was that children s environments have an effect on their cognitive and
behavioural development and on childhood vulnerability (Ellis, 2005). Looking at
learning space is about more than the structures – it is about the social relationships
within the space. Space can be conceptualized as being an interaction between physical
and social spaces. McGregor claims that the space is made by the social aspects
(McGregor, 2004). This attitude is increasing in popularity as we move again towards
creating more open spaces to improve social interactions and pupil learning
opportunities.
If it is during English lesson, then the teacher may have a corner of the classroom
set up like a theatre where the pupils could act out scenes from various plays that they
are reading. There could be an area of the classroom with comfortable chairs and a
small library where they could pick a book to silently read if they have finished all of
their work for the day. This could be viewed as warm and inviting for a learner who
does not like to read because now they see that English lesson can involve moving
around. The small library will also allow them to choose what they want to read, rather
than them having to read what was assigned (Grubaugh & Houston, 1990 Hannah,
2013).
In a Social Studies classroom, the ECDE teachers could use the concept of
creating a separate learning centre in various ways throughout the curriculum. If the
pupils were learning about World War I the teacher could organize the desks into
trenches so when the pupils walked in they would pick a side and learn how battles
were fought with this new strategy. The desks could be set in a continuous line where
each learner will have to work on only one problem of an assignment to show the
structure of an assembly line (Grubaugh & Houston, 1990; Hannah, 2013). Science
classrooms need to have set up areas to conduct various experiments. Math classrooms
need to have an activity centre (corner) focused on real world applications of the
content they are learning for that unit (Hannah, 2013). Music classrooms could have a
corner where they can listen to audio clips of great musicians from the past. Every
subject area can utilize the concept of a centre of learning that is separate from the main
structure of the class (Grubaugh & Houston, 1990 Hannah, 2013). Another method that
can be utilized by ECDE teachers is how they organize their desks and instructional
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
350
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
resources in class. A pupil will notice this rather quickly on how their teacher uses this
tool can set the tone for the rest of the school year (Gaurdino & Fullerton, 2010). Many
learners know that if they are disruptive they will get attention. Wanting attention does
not have to be a bad thing (Hannah, 2013). However, a teacher can organize their
classroom where pupils can interact with others and stay focused on the content at the
same time. If the learner can meet their individual desires while staying engaged in the
curriculum, then there would be likely less disruptive behaviour hence a pupil will
learn. One way to do this is to organize desks into groups. This allows for pupils to do
individual work if they are required, or they can work with their colleagues or peers on
specific assignments given to them by their teachers. If learners are creating larger
projects in class they can work as a whole table group to complete it, each with their
own specific task (Gaurdino & Fullerton, 2010). This arrangement will ensure that they
acquire related competencies to aid in their learning. The current study determined
whether these kinds of arrangement were existing in West Pokot County public ECDE
centres.
Another way to modify the classroom seating arrangement is to organize the
desks in a circle around the classroom. This will work better with smaller class sizes,
but can still be used occasionally in others. This strategy works well with promoting
public speaking and classroom debate (Campbell, 2008). This arrangement engages
learners because they all become one member of the same group. They are prone to
listen more actively and make more eye contact with the person who is speaking
(Grubaugh & Houston, 1990 in Hannah, 2013). It also allows the person speaking to
take more ownership of their ideas (Cornelius & Rupert, 2004). In this model, the
teacher has to make sure to create an environment where pupils feel invited to share
their views without fear of judgment in class. In order to do this the teacher must make
sure that the learners know the consequences of inappropriate behaviour. It is also a
good teaching point on how to respect people who have different opinions than their
own. To help pupils understand what is expected of them the teacher can clearly state
the order in which the discussion will run. By letting the pupils know what is expected
of them they will have clear guidelines to be held accountable to. The teacher can also
vary the method of discussion to break routine for the pupils. One day they can take
turns speaking clockwise. Another day they can call on people to speak next. There can
even be days where the teacher draws names from a bowl at random until everyone has
spoken (Hannah, 2013). The evidence above shows the significance of Indoor Classroom
Environmental Setting towards improving provision of quality education in ECDE
centres.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
351
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Teacher classroom organization may also play significant role in pupil s
discipline. When a learner walks into a classroom and sees that there is a large mess on
the teacher s desk and items scattered around the floor the pupil can get the idea that
the teacher doesn t pay a lot of attention to detail. With this mind set, the pupil may
begin to look at what other flaws the teacher might have. If a teacher does not show that
they care about organization then a pupil will most likely develop that attitude as well
(Grubaugh & Houston, 1990 in Hannah, 2013). A teacher can use this knowledge to
their advantage, however, by structuring their classroom in an organized fashion. They
can post the rules on the wall so that each pupil knows exactly what is expected of them
and the consequences if they choose not follow them. They can keep resources in a
single location that is easily accessible to the pupils. They can have specific files where
they turn in work or find missing assignments. These all will promote organization
among pupils because the learners will now have a model after which to structure
things in their own lives. Also, it will show the learners that the teacher cares about
detail and will most likely catch the pupil trying to get away with things that are
against the rules (Grubaugh & Houston, 1990 in Hannah, 2013).
Another aspect of the classroom that is difficult to control but can play a large
part in keeping learners engaged is the classroom temperature (hotness / coldness /
ventilation). This can become a complicated aspect to modify in the classroom since
many ECDE schools do not have standardised ventilation. Too cold or too warm of a
classroom can make pupils sluggish or inattentive. Also, poor circulation of air can
create dust or air pollution that can affect learners allergies. ‚ classroom with fresh,
warm air can create an atmosphere conducive to learning (Burke & Burke-Samide,
2004). Pupils will look for anything to distract them from the lesson, regardless of how
trivial it may seem. Removing problems created by things such as temperature, light, or
sound removes potential distractions for students (Hannah, 2013). This study
determined whether public ECDE classrooms classes were ventilated in West Pokot
County. According to Worthington (2008), the second element is having an
understanding of the elements of language acquisition and development that is
indispensable when helping to nurture children s language development. This element
includes the phonological skills, narrative skills, conversation skills, and the first
language of the children and how these intertwine and facilitate during and for
language development (Miske & Dowd, 2008). It is important to be able to use
effectively teaching strategies that can help facilitate communication between children
in the classroom (Worthington, 2008). Professionals have heavily recommended the
teaching strategies described and often the strategies lack a strong research basis that
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
352
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
ties the use of the strategy to achievement or later academic skills and success (Grimo,
2008).
Creating a language rich classroom is an essential part of creating an overall
environment that encourages and promotes learning (Gersten & Jimenez, 1998). De
Atiles and Allexsaht-Snider (2002) suggested labelling objects and area around the
classroom in the children s first languages and in the dominant language, usually
English. Another recommendation for creating a language rich classroom is to have an
assortment of print and language materials in both the children s first languages and in
English) available to the children, such as books, writing supplies, and books on tape or
CD (Worthington, 2008). The language materials should provide engaging experiences
for the children to use to experiment with the various modes of communication:
listening, reading, writing and talking in English and in the first language
(Worthington, 2008). Labelling areas and objects in the room is another way of
incorporating written language in the environment (Kostelnic, Soderman & Whiren,
2007). A language rich environment is also created when children have opportunities to
have books read aloud. When children are read to, they are learning new vocabulary
and print awareness (Gersten & Jimenez, 1998). Research has indicated when an adult
and one child read a children s story together, the child comprehends more of the story
than when the child is part of a group listening to a book being read (Wasik & Bond,
2001). It is possible the increased outcomes for one-on-one reading are because the adult
is able to tailor the reading pace to meet the child s ability, point out and explain what is
happening in the pictures to help engage the child in story, and the adult is able to
pause and explain unfamiliar words or to answer a question the child has about the
story (Sattar, 2013). These researchers also found out that when an adult reads to a
child, it leads to greater vocabulary retention, especially when the adult asks the child
about the story using open-ended questions.
Incorporating rhymes, poetry, and chants are methods of encouraging children
to experiment with language (Gersten & Jimenez, 1998). Using songs, poetry, rhymes,
chants, and finger plays are recommended as developmentally appropriate practice
(Kostelnik, Soderman, & Whiren, 2007). These activities support and enhance language
and literacy acquisition in children (Kostelnic, Soderman & Whiren, 2007). In a research
review, Restrepo and Gray (2007) state that the repetition often found in songs, rhymes,
and finger plays facilitates children s awareness of the language structures being used.
They note these activities also increase children s awareness of the components of
meaning and sounds in the words being used. These skills are important as children
begin to read as they sound out the letters in unfamiliar words (Kostelnic, Soderman &
Whiren, 2007). However, they did not address how these activities can be used with
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
353
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
children from diverse linguistic backgrounds and how these activities affect ELs
English acquisition and development. Having a designated book area in the classroom
is one method for providing children with opportunities to interact with books and
printed language (Gersten & Jimenez, 1998). In this area, children are able to look at
books on their own or have an adult read to them. Children learn new vocabulary and
print awareness when an adult reads to them (Gersten & Jimenez, 1998). In a research
review, Justice, Pence, and Wiggins (2008) discussed the important of multiple readings
and exposure to the same books. They noted when children experience multiple
reading sessions of the same book, they are more likely to acquire and retain expressive
and receptive vocabulary. It was also noted multiple readings or exposures to the same
books provides children with a sense of familiarity of the book content, which creates a
sense of confidence in their pre-reading skills and reinforces their confidence in their
pre-reading skills. During reading activities with an adult, the adult is able to facilitate
the children s awareness of print.
According to Justice, Pence and Wiggins (2008), adults provide instruction about
print when they read to children and reference the print on the page, for example
tracing the words with their finger. Helping the children developing confidence in their
pre-reading skills is important as the children begin to understand the concept that
words and letters carry meaning. It is suggested a quiet area be provided for children
to have a place for them to go to rest and engage in a quiet activity, such as sitting and
watching, looking at a book, or completing puzzles (Gordon & Browne, 2004) to get
away from a more physically active activity. Woolner and Hall (2010) reviewed the
weight of evidence in relation to noise, considering what implications the results of
empirical studies have for the design and use of learning spaces in schools. They found
out that noise over a given level does appear to have a negative impact on learning.
Secondly that beneath these levels noise may or may not be problematic, depending on
the social, cultural and pedagogical expectations of the students and teachers. Thirdly
they argue that when noise is deemed to be a difficulty, this finding cannot simply be
translated into design prescriptions. The reasons for this indeterminacy include
differing understandings of the routes through which noise produces learning deficits,
as well as relationships between noise and other elements of the environment,
particularly the impacts of physical solutions to noise problems.
Minchen
studied the effects of a learner s location in the classroom versus
their retention and application of newly learned material. The study's participants were
learners taking Regents Chemistry in a suburban school located in Upstate New York.
Through a teacher administered questionnaire, students answered three questions
regarding the lesson that was just presented. Results showed that learners who sat in
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
354
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
the front of the classroom, defined as the first two seats in each row, consistently did
better than those towards the back of the classroom. Various distractions such as
windows, ventilators and other learners were also taken into consideration. Simmons,
Carpenter, Crenshaw and Hinton (2015) study determined if a specific classroom
seating arrangement contributed to learners being on or off-task while completing
independent work within the general education setting of an inclusive second grade
class in South East United States. Three classroom seating arrangements were compared
in a second grade classroom. These seating arrangements were cluster seating,
horseshoe seating, and row seating. There were specific targeted off-task behaviors that
were observed: inappropriate talking, learners out of their seats without permission,
learners not following directions, and learners not starting independent work promptly.
Data was collected using three methods: observation/ anecdotal record, teacher
behavior checklist, and a behavior tally sheet. The data revealed the number of pupils
who displayed off-task behaviors as well as the specific amount of times, these
behaviors happened during each seating arrangement. They found out that row seating
had the fewest off-task behaviors for this particular second grade class. It was also
evident that inappropriate talking was the most frequent occurring off-task behavior
and not following directions was the least off-task behavior observed. For this
particular classroom, row seating was the best classroom arrangement.
Wannarka and Ruhl (2010) determined which arrangements of desks best
facilitated positive academic and behavioural outcomes for primary through secondary
high school learners with a range of characteristics. Eight studies that investigated at
least two of three common arrangements (like rows, groups or semi-circles) were
considered. Results indicate that teachers should let the nature of the task dictate
seating arrangements. Evidence supports the idea that students display higher levels of
appropriate behavior during individual tasks when they are seated in rows, with
disruptive students benefiting the most. The study by Wannarka and Ruhl collected
secondary data while this study collected mainly primary data to determine the
influence of seating arrangements on provision of quality education in ECDE. Assefa
(2014) assessed the practices and challenges of Early Childhood Care and Education in
Addis Ababa by looking at Arada Sub-City government kindergartens. The research
used a descriptive survey method which combined both quantitative and qualitative
approaches, however more emphasis to quantitative approach. Data for the research
was collected 11 nursery schools through various means from 11 head teachers (1 not
responded), 77 teachers (2 not responded), 44 parents/guardians and 2 ECDE education
experts. Findings showed that sample kindergartens were not that much conducive for
all children. They had narrow classes, they had great number of children in the classes
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
355
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
(overcrowded), there was low participation of parents and stakeholders. There was lack
of training school head teachers, teachers, experts and parents and guardians were
found to be great barriers to implement Early Childhood Care and Education in the
country. Absences of experience sharing of kindergartens, limited support system of
supervision and collaboration of stakeholders are the other barriers of the
kindergartens. The study by Assefa (2014) was in Ethiopia while this study looked to
see whether the environment of public ECDE centres in West Pokot County were
similar with those in Ethiopia.
Waithanji, Ciera, Musyoka and Moses Oketch (2013) examined the contribution
of classroom pupils seating positions to learning gains. Data was gathered from a
sample of 1907 standard six pupils who sat for the same seat twice over an interval of
about 10 months. They were drawn from a random selection of 72 low and high
performing primary schools. Results of a multi-level regression showed that seating in
the front row in a classroom led to higher learning gains of between 5 percent and 27
percent compared to seating in other rows that are farther away from the chalkboard.
The policy implication to education was that learner s seating position can be
manipulated in a way that it optimizes learning gains for slow learners. The study by
Waithanji et al, focused on seating arrangement on learners gains in primary schools
while this study looked at the influence of seating arrangement and provision of quality
education in public ECDE centres in West Pokot County.
3.3 Materials and Methods
The study was conducted in West Pokot County, Kenya. The research adopted a
descriptive survey research design. The target population includes all pubic primary
head teachers, ECDE teachers of all public pre-primary schools and DICECE officers in
West Pokot County, Kenya. The study used probability and non-probability sampling
methods in selecting the respondents for the study. In choosing the sample size, 10% of
the head teachers were selected to participate in the study while 30% of ECDE teachers
were selected to participate. The total sample size for the research is 246 which
comprises of 37 head teachers, 205 teachers and 4 DICECE officers from the four subcounties in the county. This is adequate and was a representative of the whole
population.
Data collection was done using a questionnaire, interview and observation
checklist. Field data for this research was analysed through use of two methods;
quantitative and qualitative methods.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
356
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
4. Research Results
4.1 Influence of Indoor Classroom Environment Setting on Provision of Quality
Education in Public ECDE Centres
The objective of the research was to determine how indoor classroom environmental
setting affected provision of quality education in public ECDE centres in West Pokot
County. Indoor classroom environment setting has to be standardised and set in a way
that teaching and learning is not disrupted. To answer the second research question,
teachers were asked to indicate their perception on how they rated their indoor
classroom environmental setting affected provision of quality education on statements
made in five Likert scale (SD-Strongly Disagree, D-Disagree, U-Undecided, A-Agree
and SA-Strongly Agree). The results of the analysis are presented in Table 4.1.
Table 1: Teacher Perceptions on the Influence of Indoor Classroom Environment Setting on
Provision of Quality Education
Variable
SD
D
U
A
SA
f
26
51
30
72
26
sleeping amongst learners
%
12.7
24.9
14.6
35.1
12.7
There is enough space in the classroom for easy
f
25
82
47
34
17
movement
%
12.2
40.0
22.9
16.6
8.3
The classroom is easily accessible by all learners
f
37
73
21
51
23
(even disabled)
%
18.0
35.6
10.2
24.9
11.2
Our classrooms have nature corners for enhancing
f
17
25
38
99
26
teaching and learning
%
8.3
12.2
18.5
48.3
12.7
Our classrooms have proper lighting to ensure good
f
46
83
26
29
21
condition in class
%
22.4
40.5
12.7
14.1
10.2
Pupils can be able to write their work well because
f
30
83
26
54
12
the desks and tables are not high
%
14.6
40.5
12.7
26.3
5.9
f
15
19
25
97
49
%
7.3
9.3
12.2
47.3
23.9
The classroom is well ventilated and this ensures that
there is adequate supply of air thereby minimising
I regularly ensure that physical sitting arrangement
in orderly manner to ensure interaction between
learners and I
Mean perception on Indoor Classroom
Environmental Setting
Mean
SD
3.1024
1.26965
2.6878
1.13763
2.7561
1.31322
3.4488
1.11740
2.4927
1.26654
2.6829
1.18071
3.7122
1.14622
3.1282
1.20448
Key: SD-Strongly Disagree, D-Disagree, U-Undecided, A-Agree and SA-Strongly Agree
Result show from Table 1 shows that that only 72 (35.1%) of teachers agreed and that
their classes were well ventilated to ensure that there was adequate supply of fresh air.
The responses show that 37.6% of teachers disagreed and 47.8% agreed with the
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
357
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
statement which suggested respondents were undecided (M=3.1 and SD=1.26) as
standard deviation scores are far away from the mean. This shows that only 47.8% of
ECDE classrooms in west Pokot County are ventilated and this ensures that there is
adequate supply of fresh air which minimises sleeping among learners due to the
climatic conditions of the area associated with high temperature and low humidity. The
results are somewhat different to what Olaleye and Omoyayo (2009) found in Nigeria
where ventilation in 60% of schools was found to be average.
Secondly, 82 (40.0%) of teachers disagreed that their classes had enough space for
easy movement. From the findings, it is evident that 52.2% of teachers agreed that
classrooms were small and they remain undecided (M=2.68 and SD=1.13). Therefore,
teachers find it difficult to move around and assess learners while teaching. The results
coincide with UBS Optimum foundation (2013) who found very few cases where
students had insufficient seating space in Nairobi pre-schools. Some head teachers
supported the responses by teachers while others did not.
For instance, one head teacher (HT4) had this to say during interview on
Question 2:
The room is spacious, enough and adequate for learning. This influence learning
positively.
Similarly, another head teacher (HT13) also shared the same response:
The nature of ECDE classroom is modern with enough space for learners.
However, another head teacher (HT6) sided with teachers responses by
indicating that:
The classrooms are available though they are not spacious because of the number of pupils
who have been enrolled.
Another head teacher (HT17) also supported the less spacious classes by
indicating that:
The class is less improved; it requires more resources to be modern.
The responses shows that majority of ECDE classes have limited space to
accommodate and allow movement of learners and teachers in West Pokot County. To
solve the problem, some head teachers said that there are plans through the support of
county government to expand the facilities. Similar to the study findings, Jepleting
(2013) established that majority of preschool classrooms were smaller than the
recommended classroom size of 8m x 8m. Due to this, learning corners are unavailable
in most of the schools in the zone.
However, findings are inconsistent with Olaleye and Omoyayo (2009) who
found out that the learning environment of the pre-schools using the subscale scores is
fairly good (62.5. %) in Nigerian pre-schools. From the above findings and discussions,
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
358
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
it can be seen that small classrooms size characterise provision of poor quality
education in public ECDE centres in Kenya. The crowded classrooms also limit pupils
concentration and learning. When asked as to whether the classrooms were easily
accessible by all learners irrespective of their disability status, 73 (35.6%) of teachers
disagreed with the statement. The responses shows that the respondents were
undecided on the statement (M=2.75 and SD=1.31). This implies that some classrooms
are inaccessible by learners with disabilities against the government policy of ensuring
inclusion in public primary schools. This point to poor workmanship during
construction of classes by the school management. The study coincides with Ngigi et al,
(2015) who established that schools lacked ramps for children with disabilities, as well
as rails, lower door handles, or any environmental adaptation for special needs
children.
The researcher also observed that in few classrooms that were permanent, few
had ramps with most having staircases. The research is different from what Osborne
(2013) found in New Zealand schools where access to resources (including technology):
typically a learning common is surrounded by breakout spaces allowing a range of
different activities, such as reading, group work, project space, wet areas, reflection, and
presenting. There is often a mixture of wireless and wired technology offering access as
and when students need it, within the flow of their learning. This shows that classroom
accessibility has been improved in developing countries compared to Kenya.
When asked as to whether their classes had nature corners for enhancing
teaching and learning of science, creative and mathematics activities, (48.3%) of teachers
agreed with the statement. From the result, it can be deduced that majority 61.0% of
schools have ensured that their classrooms have nature corners to facilitate learning
(M=3.45 and SD=1.1). The results are in contrast with research done by Assefa (2014)
that showed that most of respondents said that there was poor arrangement of nature
corners in their classroom. Furthermore, 83 (40.5%) of teachers agreed there classrooms
had proper lighting to enable conducive environment for learning. From the result, it is
clear that 62.9% of public ECDE centres in West Pokot County have ensured that proper
lighting is provided. The descriptive statistics also supports this view where the
respondents appeared to agree (M=3.50 and SD=1.26).
Result also showed that 83 (40.3%) of teachers disagreed with the statement that
pupils were able to write their work well because the desks and tables were not high. It
is therefore evident that majority 55.1% of desks and tables in public ECDE centres are
not comfortable for learners to write or sit on them well and this makes some to stand
while writing while others are forced to bend more to enable them write during class
teaching (M=2.68 and SD=1.18). The result also points to non-involvement of ECDE
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
359
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
teachers by school administration during the process of tendering and construction of
these resources and this could explain poor curriculum delivery in schools. The result
coincides with Mutuma (2015) who established that classroom furniture that is ill
adapted to the physical size of children is uncomfortable and can cause postural
discomfort and pain. Some centres have benches that are fixed too far from the table the
children use. This strains the child s arms when writing. Typically, children bend over
the writing table and this undesirable practice is due to combination of poor sitting
conditions and furniture misfits. However, some head teachers disagreed with teachers
opinion in Interview Question No. 6 whereby Head teacher (HT9) indicated that:
The teachers and schools have been ahead in improving the facilities to fit the learners,
e.g. the new chairs are for the aged in ECDE classes.
When asked as to whether they regularly ensured that physical sitting
arrangement was in order to ensure interaction between them and learners, 97 (47.3%)
agreed that they ensured good sitting arrangement in their classrooms. The findings
showed that majority of teachers agreed (M=3.71 and SD=1.14) with the statement. This
implies that teachers ensure that physical sitting arrangement in classrooms is in order
to ensure that interaction takes place with learners. The findings concurs with Waithanji
et al (2013) who found out that teachers can change classroom seating positions in a
way that optimizes learning achievement for every learner, since the seat position has
the potential to improve achievement gains. This therefore shows that seating
arrangement is an important factor in determining provision of quality education in
ECDE.
In general to teachers responses,
. % reported that their classroom learning
environment was not good at all by disagreeing, 14.8% held moderate perceptions on
classroom environment while 48.0% said that their indoor classroom environmental
setting was conducive to support provision of quality education. They appeared to have
mixed opinion (M=3.12 and SD=1.20). The result therefore shows that Indoor Classroom
Environmental Setting is critical to provision of quality education. However, the
challenges in classroom environment was evident by Chepkwesis (2015) study in TransNzoia County that showed that majority of the ECD teachers identified that the ECD
enrolment, the physical conditions of classrooms, the physical conditions of school
affected the pre-school classroom performance. Ngode (2014) recommended that
quality assurance and standards officers to assess if the learning environment is
conducive for young learners. To answer the research question, a cross tabulation was
conducted to determine whether there existed any association between teachers
perception on classroom learning environment setting and provision of quality
education. The results of the analysis are presented in Table 2.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
360
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Table 2: Indoor Learning Environment Setting and Quality Education Crosstabulation
Quality Education
Low
Poor
Moderate
High
Total
Count
7
11
0
18
% within learning
38.9%
61.1%
.0%
100.0%
Count
12
108
3
123
% within learning
9.8%
87.8%
2.4%
100.0%
Count
7
40
17
64
% within learning
10.9%
62.5%
26.6%
100.0%
Count
26
159
20
205
% within learning
12.7%
77.6%
9.8%
100.0%
environment setting
Learning
Moderate
environment setting
environment setting
Good
environment setting
Total
environment setting
The result (Table 2) shows that for those who considered their indoor classroom
environmental setting to be poor, 11 (61.1%) rated quality education as moderate and 7
(38.9%) rated provision of quality education as poor. For those teachers who rated
learning environment setting as average, 108 (87.8%) reported moderate provision of
quality education. For those who rated learning environmental setting in classrooms as
good, 40 (62.5%) said it was on average, 7 (10.9%) said provision was poor while 17
(26.6%) rated provision of quality education as high. From the above result, it can be
deduced that as the classroom learning environment setting improves, provision of
quality education increases and vice versa is true.
The second null hypothesis stated that:
H02
There is no significant relationship between indoor classroom environment
setting and provision of quality education in public ECDE centres.
To test the hypothesis, chi square analysis was conducted at 0.01 significance
level by cross tabulating categorical variables of indoor classroom setting; good,
moderate and poor against provision of quality education. The results of analysis are
given in Table 3.
Table 3: Chi Square Statistics on Indoor Classroom Setting and Provision of Quality Education
Value
df
Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
41.930a
4
.001
Likelihood Ratio
37.333
4
.001
Linear-by-Linear Association
20.905
1
.001
Pearson Chi-Square
N of Valid Cases
205
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
361
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Statistics shows that the computed value is x2=41.930, df=4 and p=0.001 which is
higher than the table (critical) value x2=13.277, df=4 and p=0.01 leading to rejection of
second null hypothesis and concluding that there exist significant relationship between
indoor classroom setting and provision of quality education in public ECDE centres in
West Pokot County, Kenya. This implies that schools around the four sub counties have
improved their classroom setting which is an important factor of ensuring provision of
quality education in ECDE.
The result therefore shows that there is need for improvement in classroom
setting to allow and give opportunities for all learners to study with minimal or no
interruptions. The study findings coincide with Chepkwesis (2015) who established that
majority of the ECD teachers identified that the physical conditions of classrooms
affected teachers classroom performance. In addition, Waithanji et al
established
that managing classroom indoor environments has the potential to address learning
differentials, different seating positions and arrangements should be tested for their
efficiency in instructional delivery and effectiveness in improving learning outcomes
among learners with different academic ability. From the result and discussion from
previous research, it is evident that learning environment in classroom need to be
conducive to ensure quality education is received by learners.
5. Conclusion
The physical environment in classroom was also found to be critical in ensuring
positive learning environment takes place. Teachers have to pay attention to how
physical classroom environment is as it is one of the ingredients for successful
curriculum implementation. Research results revealed that majority of classes did not
have adequate space for teacher movement while others were not well ventilated
increasing incidences of pupils sleeping while in class.
A positive finding on the indoor classroom environmental setting was the
availability of nature corners in majority of ECDE centres studied. The null hypothesis
for the study was rejected (p<0.01) leading conclusion that there existed significant
relationship between indoor classroom environment and provision of quality education
in public ECDE centres in West Pokot County. All the respondents agreed that indoor
classroom environmental setting needed adjustments and modifications to ensure that
the goals and objectives of ECDE are realised.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
362
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
6. Recommendations
To improve on classroom setting towards provision of quality education, the study
suggest that there is need for ECDE teachers to work with head teachers to ensure that
classrooms setting are safe, secure and conducive for teaching and learning process. On
the policy front, there is need for county government to work with national government
to establish appropriate standards for ideal Indoor Classroom Environmental Setting
for ECDE learners in West Pokot County. This is because the classroom environment
needs to encourage physical, emotional and intellectual development of learners which
will promote good physical and mental growth.
References
1. Ajayi, I.A., H.T. Haastrup & F.M. Osalusi
Learning Environment and
Secondary School Effectiveness in Nigeria . Study Home Comm. Science, 4(3), 137142.
2. Assefa, E. (2014). Practices and Challenges of Early Childhood Care and Education in
Addis Ababa, Arada Sub-City Government Kindergartens. MA Thesis in Special
Needs Education, Addis Ababa University.
3. Bunting, A. (2004). Secondary Schools Designed for A Purpose: But which One?
Teacher, 154, 10-13.
4. Chepkewsis, R.B. (2015).
Factors Influencing Pre-School Teachers’ Classroom
Performance in ECDE Centers In Public Schools in Kwanza Sub County, Trans-Nzoia
County, Kenya. MPhil Thesis, Moi University, Kenya.
5. Duruji, M.M., Azuh, D. & Oviasogie, F. (2014). Learning Environment And
Academic Performance Of Secondary School Students In External Examinations: A
Study Of Selected Schools In Ota. Paper presented during Proceedings of
EDULEARN14 Conference 7th-9th July 2014, Barcelona, Spain.
6. Grubaugh, S. & Houston, R.
. Establishing a Classroom Environment That
Promotes Interaction and Improved Student ‛ehaviour,
The Clearing House,
63(8), 375-378.
7. Gersten, R. M. & Jimenez, R. T. (1998). Promoting Learning for Culturally and
Linguistically Diverse Student: Classroom Applications for Contemporary Research.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
363
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
8. Greenberg, R. D., & Rodriguez, J. (Eds.). (2007). ECDE English Learners: Principles
and Practices to Promote Language, Literacy, and Learning. Sacramento: California
Department of Education.
9. Grimo,
M.
(2008).
What
is
Quality
Education?
[Online]
Available:
http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20081128/education/what-is-qualityeducation.234848.
10. Haile G. S. (2010). The Current Practice of Pre-school Education in some Selected
Woredas of Northern Western Zone of Tigray. MA Thesis .Addis Ababa University.
11. Hannah, R.,
.
The Effect of Classroom Environment on Student Learning
Honours Theses. Paper 2375.
12. Higgins, S., Hall, E., Wall, K., Woolner, P. & McCaughey, C.
5 . The Impact of
School Environments: “ Literature Review’, The Centre for Learning and Teaching,
School of Education, Communication and Language Science, University of
Newcastle.
13. Jepleting, C.S. (2013). Effect of Classroom Environment on Academic Performance in
Mathematics of ECDE Children in Pioneer Zone, Uasin Gishu County, Kenya. MED in
ECDE Project, University of Nairobi, Kenya.
14. Justice, L. M., Pence, K. L., & Wiggins, ‚.K.
. Preschool Teachers Fidelity
in Implementing a Comprehensive Language-Rich Curriculum. Language, Speech,
and Hearing Services in Schools, 39, 329-341.
15. Lewinski, P.
5 . Effects of Classrooms
‚rchitecture on ‚cademic
Performance in View of Telic Versus Paratelic Motivation: A Review. Front.
Psychol, 1-5.
16. Maxwell, L. E., Mitchell, M. R. & Evans, G. W. (2008). Effects of Play Equipment
and Loose Parts on Preschool Children s Outdoor Play ‛ehaviour: ‚n
Observational Study and Design Intervention. Children, Youth and Environments,
18(2), 36-63.
17. Minchen, ‛. J.,
.
The Effects of Classroom Seating on Students'
Performance in a High School Science Setting Education and Human Development
Master's Theses. Paper 414.
18. Miske S, & Dowd, A. (2008). Teaching and Learning in Mangochi Classrooms: A
Combining Quantitative and Qualitative Information to Study 12 Primary School in
Malawi. Evaluation Study Conducted for the United States Agency for
international Development, Washington, D.C.
19. Muthoni V. M. (2013). Influence of Parental Involvement on Academic Performance of
ECDE Children in Kangeta Division, Meru County, Kenya. Masters of Education in
Early Childhood Education Thesis, University of Nairobi.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
364
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
20. Ngigi, S.K. (2015). Assessment of the Early Childhood Development Policy
Implementation in Kenya, Case Study of Ruiru District. Journal of Education &
Social Policy, 2(1), 78-89.
21. Ngode, L.A. (2014). Impact of Supervision on the Implementation of Early Childhood
Education Curriculum in Selected Public ECDEs In Lang’ata District, Nairobi County,
Kenya.MED Masters Project in ECDE, University of Nairobi, Kenya.
22. Ngware, M., Oketch, M., & Ezeh, A.C. (2011). Quality of Primary Education
Inputs in Urban Schools: Evidence from Nairobi. Education and Urban Society,
43(1), 91-116.
23. Okudo, A.R. & Omotuyole, C. (2014). Enhanced Learning Environment and Its
Implications on the Pre- School Children s Language Performance. European
Scientific Journal, 10 (7), 405-413.
24. Olagboye, A.A. (2004). Introduction to Educational Administration Planning and
Supervision. Ikeja: Joja Educational Research and Publishers Ltd.
25. Olaleye, O. F. (2009). Creating a Friendly School Learning Environment for
Nigerian Children. European Scientific Journal, 8(8), 138-147.
26. Olaleye, O. F. & Omotayo, K.A. (2009). Assessment of Quality in Early
Childhood Education in Ekiti-State Nigeria. World Applied Sciences Journal, 7 (5),
683-688.
27. Uwezo Kenya (2012). Are our Children Learning? Annual Learning Assessment
Report. Nairobi: Uwezo Kenya.
28. Waithanji, M.N., Ciera, J., Musyoka, P. K. & Oketch, M. (2013). The Influence of
Classroom Seating Position on Student Learning Gains in Primary Schools in
Kenya. Creative Education, 4(11), 705-712.
29. Wannarka, R. & Ruhl, K. (2010). Seating arrangements that promote positive academic
and behavioural outcomes: a review of empirical research. Oxford: Blackwell
Publishing.
30. Wangari, M. (2003), Quality of Learning Environment at Early Childhood
Education Level: Is Kenya on Track? Zurückzur-Übersicht, 49-61.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
365
Mildred Chepkonga
CLASSROOM ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING AND PROVISION OF QUALITY EDUCATION IN
PUBLIC PRE-SCHOOL CENTRES IN WEST POKOT COUNTY, KENYA
Creative Commons licensing terms
Author(s) will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Education Studies shall
not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflicts of interest, copyright violations and
inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated into the research work. All the published works are meeting the Open Access
Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and non-commercial purposes
under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 3 │ Issue 4│ 2017
366