European Journal of Education Studies
ISSN: 2501 - 1111 (on-line)
ISSN-L: 2501 - 1111 (print)
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
10.5281/zenodo.55543
Volume 1│Issue 3│2016
GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR
IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING
AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
Dr. John Fungulupembe Kalolo
Lecturer, Mkwawa University College of Education,
Iringa, Tanzania
Abstract:
Changes in today s modern science education SE are both rapid and intricate, bringing
both significant challenges and new opportunities in the field of science education.
Despite their complexity, they appear to serve as a wake-up call for all science
stakeholders in the world including Tanzaniato start thinking about the changes can be
appropriately addressed and accommodated in present school curriculum. However,
along with this need, it appears that there is little understanding on what exactly these
changes are and their impact in the SE practice. This review paper intends to develop an
understanding of the nature of these changes; ascertaining their implications in the
practice of SE in secondary schools and identifying the way forward to address them.
This includes analyzing how SE can be appropriately organized to address such
changes.
Keywords: modern science education, relevant science education, functional science
education.
Introduction
The development of SE around the world has accelerated the pace of science-driven
change in modern societies, allowing science as an educational subject to become more
important than ever before (Lederman, 2008b). Lederman (2008) argues that:
We have arrived at a point in history where there must be a major increase in the
capability of ordinary people to cope with the scientific and technological culture that is
shaping their lives and the lives of their children (p. i).
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved
Published by Open Access Publishing Group ©2015.
99
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
With such an aspiration, improving SE has become of paramount importance in
determining a country s scientific status and its socio-economic power in today s open
economies. The desire to develop SE is clear and, in many countries, there is an
evidence of several opportunities to ensure that quality, relevant and sustainable SE is
provided for every student.
A review of the literature establishes that efforts to improve SE in most African
secondary schools since the
s have been impacted by a number of global
challenges (Ogunmade, 2005; Ogunniyi, 1986) which appear to have greatly influenced
SE practices in the schools. These challenges include changes related to: Science as a
discipline itself, the evolution of societal needs, new developments in technology,
scientific innovations, changes in the purposes of SE, the intensification of globalization,
changes in new theories of learning, changing labour force demands and the evolution
of the market forces in science careers. These changes seem to have altered global
educational needs and thereby challenging “frican schools
to transform their
structures and processes of education towards more relevant issues for the learners and
society at large to the functional members of the society (Stewart, 2010; Wilmarth, 2010).
Such changes have also led to a mismatch between the knowledge and skills that the
schools offer, and the competencies that school graduates need for them to face their
futures confidently.
Most developing countries face many of these challenges, the result of which
have increased the need to redefine SE practices; to make it more functional for learners
and more effective in catering for their needs, especially the needs of those learners who
choose to pursue the formal study of science beyond secondary education (Osaki,
Hosea & Ottevanger, 2004, Ogumnmade, 2004). Another pressure on SE is about the
need to address the public outcry from developing countries including parents,
employers, and the private sector, who claim that there is a huge difference between the
kind of graduates they expect and those being produced by schools, colleges and
universities with science specialisations.
Additionally there have been a number of important reports related to SE in
Africa over the past two decades, including those of Ogunniyi (1986), Osaki et al (2004)
and Ogunmade (2005) that have strongly identified the need to improve SE in schools.
Their contributions to African SE literature and their recommendations have made a
major contribution towards better understanding the status of SE in the region. The
Intention of this review paper is to build on previous studies in SE by developing an
understanding of different global changes in SE and their impact in the current practice
of SE in secondary schools found in developing countries. This intention is built around
making SE relevant, functional and sustainable and with the ability to connect the
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
100
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
school SE experiences to students daily lives as well as enabling them to play a more
functional role in society (Diut & Treagust, 2003).
The aim of study
With the intention of making SE relevant and functional to the learners in developing
countries; this review paper, intended to examine the nature of global changes in SE
and their impacts to the current SE practices in the developing countries. Specifically
the review intended to:
a) Develop an understanding about several changes in SE.
b) Ascertain the implications of these changes in the practice of SE in schools.
c) Identify the way forward to address the present global changes
It is not the intentions of this paper; however, to identify dogmas to be followed,
but rather provide the possible breakthroughs to be adapted as different countries
prepare themselves towards addressing current and future global science related
challenges. This initiative is similar to the desire of developing relevant SE systems in
developing countries, the initiative which involves the process of aligning the SE to the
values, needs and expectations of society. The paper responds to the need of SE system
being able to inform policy, citizens and politicians objectively about how the global
changes in SE can be appropriately addressed. In the following sections, the paper
briefly addresses the methodology employed in this paper.
Methodology
The methodology adopted by this review paper is a mixed form of data collecting
methods including: literature reviews, desk research, web searches, and analysis of
publicly available databases in the field of SE. It also includes governmental and
nongovernmental reports, policies, and other initiatives related to new developments
and changes in SE. The methodology was set out to examine the experiences from
national and international literature and the evidence from empirical studies about the
global changes and their implications to the current and future SE practices in
developing countries. The plan of analysis centered at reviewing only those academic
research, reports and journal articles which attempted to describe the nature of various
global changes in SE. It is envisaged that the discussion from this article will help in
preparing the developing countries to address the challenges related to the topic more
effectively. The next sub section outlines the need for discussion about this topic in
developing countries.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
101
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
The global changes in SE: Why should this be an important topic for discussion in
developing countries?
In the era of science and technology, the developing countries would need to be
knowledgeable in science to prosper in a complex and global society (Bull, Gilbert,
Barwick, Hipkins, & Baker, (2010). This ambition is underpinned by the belief that
scientifically literate citizenry is needed to make informed decisions about the nation s
health,
technological
developments,
agricultural
mechanisation,
nutrition,
environmental conservation and food preservation which all depend upon community
literacy regarding scientific principles and concepts (UNESCO, 2008).
There are a number of issues related to SE in the developing countries, which
appear to be of great concern. These include:
a)
The participation gap in SE. There has been a persisting participation gap in SE in
formal, non-formal and informal settings, across regions, cultures, gender and other
several disadvantaged groups (such as women, learners from rural areas, and learners
from poor socio-economic status) in most African countries (Anamuah-Mensah,
Mereku, & Asabere-Ameyaw, 2004). This situation not only blocks the full involvement
in society of all citizens and talents in SE but also limits their contribution to this field.
b)
The lack of interest in science careers among many students. This is demonstrated by
the situation whereby many students have been turning away from science studies and
related careers. The issue of developing interest in SE is essential in meeting the
demand for well-prepared graduates (at all levels) and researchers, necessary for our
knowledge and innovation-intensive societies and economies (Osaki, 2007; Osborne &
Dillon, 2008).
c)
The poor schooling environment. This includes the lack of competent teachers who
are able to inspire their students, inappropriate professional development training
among teachers as well as an absence of interesting and motivating curricula
(Lederman, 2008; Osaki et al., 2004). There is also a lack of clear shared standards for SE
that would help all involved in the system to set and achieve goals (Reddy, 2006). As a
result, too many students conclude early in their education that science subjects are too
difficult, unfavorable, or boring and without future, and in most cases the training in SE
leaves them inadequately prepared to face challenges in their futures.
d)
Lack of a science capable community. Despite the fact that science is important, even
for people who are not planning to become engineers, mathematicians or scientists
(Holbrook, 2010; Osborne & Dillon, 2008), most of developing countries arguably lack a
science capable community. An increasing number of jobs today draw on at least some
knowledge or skill from science fields and every occupation has the potential to be
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
102
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
transformed by scientific and technological advances. This situation presents the need
for citizens in the developing countries to have an understanding of science and
technology, the knowledge that could help them to make informed decisions about
issues facing their nations and the planet at large.
e)
Lack of science-proficient workforce. The nation s ability to solve problems and
achieve economic growth seems to largely depend on cultivating a future workforce
that is science literate. This need is urgent in developing countries because the region s
economy needs a large and an increasing supply of workers who can use scientific
knowledge and skills in their jobs to fuel scientific discoveries, innovations and
entrepreneurship (Ogunmade, 2005).
f)
Lack of future science experts. The developing countries need a steady stream of the
best science researchers and innovators and a large pool of science experts with the
knowledge and desire to advance science and technology in the country (Bybee, &
Fuchs, 2006; 2010). Science experts can play an important role in providing knowledge
that serves a nation in various socio-economic and cultural issues such as security,
mining, communication and transportation. They can also help to develop the new
ideas and inventions necessary for the country s technological development as well as
inspiring and mentoring new generations of scientists, engineers and mathematicians.
This group of professionals is likely to contribute immensely to economic growth,
technological progress as well as developments in high-tech industries, medical
research centres and engineering firms. More importantly, they also help in retaining
these advantages by building a strong science expertise.
g)
Some limitations related to the way SE is practiced in schools. Despite clear and
well-focused intent to strengthen the scientific knowledge base among the public,
experiences reveal that instead of making sure that science students are provided with
quality SE experiences, practices in developing countries still seem to be limited to the
following: Preparation of students for examinations at the expense of developing
conceptual knowledge about science, the absence of practical work experience in some
of schools, a situation which limits the students from developing procedural knowledge
in science and the absence of clear delineation about the nature of science and its
relationship with other disciplines (Hipkins et al, 2002; Tytler, 2007).
h)
Extensive demand of knowledge to use digital technology: The demand for knowledge
in digital technologies is intensely and extensively throughout all aspects of
contemporary life. From children entering school now to the old generation retiring in
science careers altogether require the knowledge of digital technology.
i)
Unevenness in basic science literacy across the entire region. The literacy in basic
science is necessary to ensure a rigorous understanding and use of scientific knowledge
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
103
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
in decision-making, particularly in domains such as health, the environment, food,
energy and consumption. The evidence from developing countries shows that the
region is not doing well in terms of how science can be made useful to solve both the
contextual and global science related challenges.
These issues are complex and multi-factorial, but the good news is that there is
an opportunity to create long-term added value through enhanced scrutiny on how
these global changes and their related challenges in SE can be handled and sustainably
addressed through the schooling system. The developments of these challenges have
quickened not only the need to do something worthwhile in SE but also have created
the necessity to connect SE to the daily societal issues. These challenges also are placing
new demands on the governments, educational institutions, businesses and civil society
organizations to meet the evolving needs of society and the workplace. The failure to
address these demands is similar to straining the existing resources, including: energy,
environment, food, water, housing, communication, social cohesion and culture.
Looking at these concerns and considering how influential on contemporary SE they
have been, it is considered important to write this review paper, especially at this time
when SE has become a common topic for most national media, public talks and policy
debates. Investing efforts to understand the global changes in SE with the intention of
addressing them appears to be an inevitable option.
How SE practices have changed over time?
SE practices worldwide show that the structure of SE has remained relatively
unchanged for the last half-century, and also that its practice has been similar
worldwide (Symington & Tytler, 2005; Tytler, 2007). In developing countries, the SE has
always been provided through distinct disciplinary strands, such as biology, chemistry,
engineering science, and physics; the strands which are operationalized as relatively
constant components of SE. Research evidence towards the end of twentieth century
has revealed that the practice of SE has concentrated in the developing literacy in three
strands of SE which include: developing conceptual knowledge (content), developing
procedural knowledge (how to do science) and the nature of science (learning about
science). However, the current focus of SE in developing countries seems to be centre at
three basic concerns; two of these have traditionally been framed as more important
than the third.
Historically, questions about the nature of science have been framed as less
relevant, however currently, and internationally, curricula are giving the nature of
science a bigger emphasis (Bull, Gilbert, Barwick, Hipkins& Baker, 2010). This focus is
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
104
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
one which is still shaping most science classrooms today. Both UNICEF and UNESCO
also recognize five major emphases in today s education SE in this case which include:
acquisition of survival skills; supporting the objectives of peace, citizenship and
security; development of cognitive, emotional and creative capacities among learners;
promoting equality, and seeking to pass global and local cultural values down to future
generations (UNICEF, 2009; UNESCO, 2008).
Underpinning the view by UNESCO and UNICEF is the economic, sociocultural, political and technological developments in today s world, which are
increasingly described as shaped and directed by science (Osborne & Dillon, 2008). This
means that most socio-political, economical, scientific and technological developments
in today s world depend on not only the quality but also relevance, functionalism and
context responsiveness of SE that each country is able to provide to the current and
future generations of its citizens.
Today the education processes and reforms, especially those related to SE, are
challenged by the constant changes in the education environment, world-wide
competition, globalisation of markets, high customer demands, changing educational
stakeholders, and the long-lasting impacts of information technology, global economic
instability, and strong demands for economic and social development (Bull, Gilbert,
Barwick, Hipkins & Baker, 2010). The shift towards increased attention in SE appears to
be a popular song of most education systems in developing countries. This is probably
because the high quality SE systems have been identified as central enablers for
individual countries and learners being able to respond appropriately to a variety of
social and cultural challenges (Education Queensland, 2004; Holt, 2000; Kubow &
Fossum, 2003). The emergence of these new developments reveals a changing focus
regarding SE practice.
New trends and changes in SE
The current SE appears to be driven by complex and conflicting variables that feature
rapidly growing transformations marked by new discoveries and progress in all
spheres of human activity, including economic, social, cultural and political (Bull et al,
2010; OECD-GSF, 2006; 2007). One notable consequence of these transformations is the
pressure to redefine the school SE practices to enable citizens to deal with the challenges
in the modern world.
Drawing from this ambition it appears inevitable for most, if not all, developing
countries to make SE contextually relevant and functional for students in solving the
challenges they encounter in life (OECD-GSF, 2006; Ogunniyi, 1986). Despite the
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
105
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
outlined need of these countries, studies argue that the SE provided in schools in most
developing countries need to be reframed so as to offer the knowledge and skills
needed for the scientific and technological development of those countries (Ogunniyi,
1986; OECD-GSF, 2006; Osaki, et al., 2004). As a result of this requirement, both
structural and procedural reforms of SE have been unavoidable.
In this modern era of information, evidence shows some new emphases and
thoughts in the practice of SE. For instance, there is increasing emphasis on the
processes versus the products of science, an emphasis on better linking science with its
technological and social implications (as opposed to the current emphasis on inquiry as
a predominant feature of school science), an emphasis on context and a supportive
learning environments (as opposed to established approaches to teaching that favoured
universalisation of science content and pedagogy), an emphasis of technological
inventions and scientific discoveries as opposed to dwelling on consumption of other s
technology and scientific discoveries) (Bull et al., 2010). These newly emerging areas of
emphasis appear to challenge the structure and processes of SE in today s schools.
According to Bull et al. (2010) and Tytler (2007), the changing conditions and
emphases in SE demand some modifications on how SE is planned, practiced and
monitored in today s schools. These changes include:
1. The changing practice of science from the traditional role of the scientist. This includes
shifting from viewing science as an individually controlled pursuit to viewing it
as commercial, multi-disciplinary, and technologically linked to bigger projects,
which have impact on the larger community (Goodrum, Hackling, & Rennie,
2001).
2. Increasing emphasis on providing opportunities for scientific discussion,
extended scientific inquiries and debate among students versus presenting
scientific knowledge through lecture, text, demonstration, and rigidly orienting
the learners towards acquisition of information
3. Changing focus of science from focusing on student acquisition of discrete
information towards looking at science a body of knowledge to be studied so
that it can inspire citizens to use evidence-based reasoning for decision making;
develop confidence, knowledge and skills among the citizens so that they
participate actively in an increasingly complex scientific and technological world;
as well as developing analytical and critical thinking that are necessary to
empower citizens to lead personally fulfilling, socially responsible and
professionally-engaged lives;
4. The changing practice on the way the public engages with and responds to science and its
products. The public has shifted from viewing science as a purely academic
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
106
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
discipline to viewing it as a necessary undertaking for managing resources and
mastering socio-economic problems (Aikenhead, 2001; 2006).
5. The increasing attacks on science as a body of knowledge. Modern science is
increasingly being attacked as being dogmatic, universalistic and for its claim as
being humanity s most powerful knowledge, more truthful and functional than
any of the others (Symington & Tytler, 2005).
6. The increasing knowledge explosion. New theories are overthrowing the old ones,
new science information is being assimilated into old, unverifiable hypotheses
are being discarded, hypotheses supported by evidence are being treated with
greater confidence, and continuously rechecking scientific results, while tentative
theories are published in scientific publications. All this must be assimilated by
SE (Aikenhead, 2006; Tytler, 2007).
7. The changing nature of learning science. This is exemplified by a shifting emphasis
from teacher-centred and content-centred learning to student-centred learning.
This shift is promising to reduce the unnecessary difficulty of school science
learning to an interesting discipline of study enjoyed by all (Fletcher, 2003).
8. The changing audience for science education. This is marked by a shifting emphasis
from science being only for a few selected people to science being open to all.
Practically, this is represented by making science compulsory for all up to high
school, including those not destined for post-training in SE careers. While
science for all is still contestable, this change has led to a need for SE practices to
be redefined to accommodate diverse student populations with a wide range of
responses towards what is essential and worthy learning in science (Fensham,
2011).
9. Changing focus from science knowledge consumption to knowledge creation and
amendment. This focus marks the shifting emphasis of scientists from being
consumers of others knowledge to being knowledge creators, developers and
amenders. This emphasis brings the importance of enabling scientists to become
innovators, technology inventors, and scientific architects. This shift of practices
challenges the developing countries which for a long time been consumers of
western science and technological discoveries to start rethinking on how they can
take lead of developing relevant and contextually functional SE.
Given such a global evidence of in the practice of SE, and the changing needs of
society, there is an urgent need to act promptly in preparation on how such challenges
can be appropriately addressed in the schooling system. This initiative is likely to help
not only to improve the relevance of the SE offered in light of the existing challenges
but also it is likely to improve the motivation and interest of students to choose science
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
107
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
studies and their related careers as their future professions. The global changes
highlighted so far seem to put pressure on today s SE systems all over the world to start
thinking of developing programs or measures which take advantage of the present
science workforce, and the remarkable opportunity offered by the internet for global
improvement of SE in terms of its relevance to the society.
While there is evidence of bright spots in developed world where innovative
approaches seem to be having some success in the practice of SE; the evidence from
developing countries still show a state of inadequacy in SE. “lthough researchers
efforts in developing countries have made progress in addressing the challenges related
to global changes in SE, these efforts seem to be not enough, the governments can also
be blamed for showing little commitments in improving SE. This situation has
ultimately led to the weak scientific and technological foundations of SE in most of the
countries (Fensham, 2004). It is perhaps surprising that in this global era, where SE
holds the first priority in socio-economic development, most developing countries still
embraces weak SE frameworks which have failed to capture critical issues in SE that
could sustain the countries desires to provide functional and relevant SE to the public.
Unlike the poor trend of SE in most developing countries, evidence also shows
that there has been growing demand for the public to engage with science and
applications of science in the form of rapidly developing technologies such as
computers and mobile phones (Hamilton et al., 2010). However, SE practices in schools
are still focused on the preparation of students who know and can consume large
amounts of scientific information, but are unable to develop the creative and innovative
skills necessary for their survival nor are they able to use the learnt knowledge to
address and possibly solve science related social issues (BouJaoude, 2006). Most SE
systems in the developing countries are blamed for their failure to develop individual
learners into sound, effective citizens and self-dependent individuals who are able to
respond to the contextual pressures and overcome the existing challenges.
Implication of global changes in the practice of SE
As modern civilization has developed, there has been a need for regular refocusing of
SE in every country in the world (Osborne & Dillon, 2008). In the context of developing
countries there have been a variety of projects initiated to improve the quality of SE, all
of which have focused on improving the way SE is enacted in schools (Fensham, 2009;
Osaki et al 2004). In many situations, however, these projects had been limited by scope
and duration, contextual and cultural limitations, with dilemmas in what to address
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
108
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
and who to target. As a result, these projects have not impacted positively in the public
literacy in SE (Osaki, 2007).
In the pursuit of new visions and aims at different levels of education the need
for life-long learning, global networking, international outlook and the use of
information and technological power has arisen to ensure that the aims, content,
practices and outcomes of education are relevant and functional for present and future
generations (UNICEF, 2009; UNESCO, 2005). Along with new development, there are
some challenges which greatly impede the efficient practice of SE. One of these
challenges is a failure to develop strong scientific community and skilled manpower in
the field (Hodson, 2014). According to Bybee (2006) and Osaki et al (2004), the
development of scientifically skilled manpower is only possible when the provision of
relevant SE is a central concern. This situation explains why various strategies are being
put in place in developing countries to ensure their citizens are scientifically literate
(World Bank, 2011).
Achieving public scientific literacy and be able to benefit from a well performing
SE system, it is no longer helpful to think about improving SE practice merely in terms
of maintaining standards and closing the eyes not see what goes on out there (Fensham,
2004). Instead, Srikanthan and Dalrymple, (2003) suggest taking a developmental
approach by pragmatists who articulate on the need to refocus SE based the existing
challenges and promising practices. This approach focuses on building a direct
connection between the SE offered in schools to the realities out there. The
developmental approach would exist in the form of multi-involvement practices, where
policy makers and planners, educators, communities, parents, teachers, students and
other stakeholders in educational decisions are involved in a strategy for creating
relevance, ownership and accountability for their children s education Delputte,
.
The implication drawn from these emerging changes in SE indicates that there is
a need to readdress the way SE is viewed and enacted, particularly so that it is made
relevant and functional for the public (Aikenhead, 2001). Achieving this goal demands
not only a clear and focused change to the way SE is planned, practiced, evaluated and
monitored but also a reflective approach of what is happening in the world, and what
could be the best option to adapt. In such a process Tytler (2007) suggests for the
necessity to prioritize the following in the practice of SE : Ascertaining the sort of
knowledge worth knowing and its ability to serve the future needs of students as
responsible citizens; accepting that
SE ends are acknowledged and adapted in
informing the practice; allowing that a variety of voices and interests to be included
when
charting a way forward for relevant SE, and acknowledging the set of
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
109
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
circumstances controlling the implementation of the whole process of providing quality
SE in schools.
Moreover the current situation of SE in developing countries, also suggest that
greater attention should be given towards:
Promoting appropriate science research and innovation whose outcomes are
likely to help in addressing the global challenges in SE.
international levels, taking into account societal needs and global developments.
the underlying consequences.
Connecting innovation and SE strategies, at local, regional, national, and
Involvement of international partners in addressing the critical issues in SE and
Active and direct involvement of the society in science research and innovation
projects.
The new development in today s SE also appear to suggest for concerted efforts
in building curiosity about the world around us, learning to act and think like a scientist
and understanding the nature of science, all of which provide a solid foundation for
future success. It is only by relevant and functional SE that developing countries can
build upon everyday experiences and thus being able to develop strong relationship
between what is taught in the classroom and the world around them. This is similar to
shifting the focus of SE from learning discrete scientific facts to understanding how to
apply science learning to new situations. This initiative would help in transforming
knowledge into usable forms which in turn could help in producing positive attitudes
towards science – a vital requirement for active, responsible citizenship.
Collaboration between science educationalists, formal, non-formal and informal
educational providers, research centres, enterprise, industry, civil society, and other
professionals, appear to be another necessary aspect in an attempt to address critical
global issues in SE. This initiative is important in that it is likely to ensure meaningful
engagement of all societal actors in science and thus increasing the uptake of science
studies and science-based careers; help in increasing interest in science and sciencecareers and offer exciting ways to address critical issues in SE.
Looking at situation of the fast changing citizens needs and the multi-facetted
nature of the task to address the global challenges in SE; it is strongly recommended in
this paper that the individual countries in the developing countries need to bring
together key actors from within the states to initiate a participatory consultation and
dialogue process across the region on the promising actions for successful discussion
about the global challenges in SE. This is an important initiative for a collective vision
and shared sense of accountability, responsibility and innovation by all society s
stakeholders from educational institutions (such as schools, colleges, universities),
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
110
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
business enterprises, and other small groups (such as families, teachers and students),
to the public and civil society organizations. Basically the efforts to address the global
challenges in SE should involve all members of the developing countries, at local,
regional, national level, acting together in a coherent and integrated way.
Conclusion
As the world becomes more inter-connected and globally competitive in all facets of
life, often these changes appear to come hand in hand with complex dynamics that
happen to influence the educational practice (SE in this particular case). There is
substantial scientific agreement about the occurrence, causes, and consequences of
global change in the practice of SE. Yet due to the inherent complexity of the topic, the
social controversies, confusion and doubt often persist. As such there appears to be a
need of developing a clear understanding of the nature of these changes, the worthiness
of being addressed and their notable impacts in the practice of SE in developing
countries. The ability to address this need depends on the current best scientific
understanding of the topic.
The paper presents the need of creating awareness among the public about SE
dynamics, so that the public can participate actively and responsibly in making
informed decision about several SE issues that directly impact their lives. The paper
provides not only the direction concerning increasing the relevance of SE in developing
countries but also identifies the challenges resulted from the global changes and how
these challenges can be effectively addressed. It is also evident in the paper that for
developing countries to achieve the ambitious goal of providing relevant, functional
and context responsive SE there is a need for all citizens to have a better understanding
of SE and its related dynamics if they are to participate actively and responsibly in
science-informed decision-making and knowledge-based innovation. This initiative
should be focused at making sure that the SE provided in schools is made more
responsive to the needs and ambitions of society and reflect its values.
Furthermore, the paper recognizes that there is a need to develop the direct
connection between the SE delivered and society needs and expectation. This initiative
is important in that clear articulation of the global challenges in SE is likely to enable to
be able to make scientifically informed decisions about the consequences of such
changes. The importance of understanding such global changes in SE and being at good
to position to address them provides the essential foundation towards avoiding the
negative impacts that these changes have on the relevance of SE. I believe that the paper
makes a substantive contribution to the policy debate in the developing countries on
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
111
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
how best the global changes in the practice of SE can be addressed but also outlines
necessity of creating a better transformative connection between the SE provided and
society needs and expectations. However this is possible only if joint initiatives are
established to create a regional and national-wide response and dialogue processes to
effectively respond to critical issues in SE that have been so rampantly disadvantageous
in the efforts to develop functional and context responsive SE in developing countries.
References
1. Anamuah-Mensah, J., Mereku, D. K., & Asabere-Ameyaw, A. (2004). Ghanaian
junior secondary school students achievement in mathematics and science: Results from
Ghana s participation in the 00 trends in international mathematics and science study,
Accra: Ministry of Education Youth and Sports.
2. Aikenhead, G. S.
. Students ease in crossing cultural borders into school
science. Science Education.85, 180-188.
3. Aikenhead, G.S. (2006). Science Education for Everyday Life: Evidence-Based Practice.
New York: Teachers College Press.
4. Bybee, R.W. (2006). Science Teaching in the 21st Century: Five Themes for
Educational Leaders. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company.
5. Bybee, R.W., & Fuchs, B. (2006). Preparing the 21st century workforce: A
newreform in science and technology education. Journal of Research in Science
Teaching 43 (4) 349–52.
6. Bybee, R. (2010). The Teaching of Science: 21st-Century Perspectives. Arlington, VA:
NSTA Press.
7. BouJaoude, S. (2006). Bridging the gap between scientists and science educators in the
Arab region: Report Presented at the Expert Group Meeting on ”ridging the Gap
between Scientists and Science Educators, organized and sponsored by the UNESCO
office, Cairo, Egypt.
8. Bull, A., Gilbert, J., Barwick, H., Hipkins, R., & Baker, R. (2010). Inspired Science: A
paper Commissioned by the Royal Society and the Prime Minister s Chief Science
Advisor. New Zealand Council for Educational Research
9. Duit, R., &Treagust, D. F. (2003). Conceptual change: A powerful framework for
improving science teaching and learning. International Journal of Science Education,
25(6), 671-688.
10. Delputte, S. (2013). The EU as an emerging coordinator in development
cooperation: perspectives from sub-Saharan Africa1. Afrika Focus, 26(1), 99-107.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
112
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
11. Fletcher, A. (2003). Meaningful Student Involvement: Guide to Inclusive School
Change. Olympia, WA: The Free child Project.
12. Fensham, P. J. (2011). Globalization of science education: Comment and a
commentary. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 48 (6), 698-709.
13. Fensham, P. J. (2009). The link between policy and practice in science education:
The role of research. Science Education, 93(6), 1076–1095.
14. Fensham, P.J. (2004). Increasing the Relevance of Science and Technology
Education for all students in the 21st century. Science Education International, 15
(1), 7-27.
15. Hamilton, M., Mahera, W. C., Mateng e, M. F. J., & Machumu, M. M.
.A
Needs Assessment Study of Tanzania Science Education. The economic and social
research foundation (ESRF), Dar es Salaam.
16. Hipkins, R., Bolstad, R., Jones, A., Barker, M., Bell, B., Coll, R., Cooper, B., Forret,
M., Harlow,
17. A., Taylor, I., France, B., & Haigh, M.J. (2002). Curriculum, Learning and Effective
Pedagogy: A Literature Review in Science Education. Wellington: Ministry of
Education.
18. Hodson, D. (2014). Learning Science, Learning about Science, Doing Science:
Different goals demand different learning methods. International Journal of Science
Education, 36 (15), 2534-2553
19. Holbrook, J. (2010). Education through science as a motivational innovation for
education for all. Science Education International, 21(2), 80-91.
20. Kubow, P. K., & Fossum, P. R. (2003). Comparative Education: Exploring Issues in
International Context. Upper Saddle River NJ: Merrill Prentice Hall.
21. Lederman, L (2008). Science education and the future of humankind, Science
News, 173(16), 1.
22. Ogunniyi, M. B. (1986). Two decades of science education in Africa. Science
Education, 70(2): 111–122
23. Ogunmade, O.T. (2005). The Status and Quality of Secondary Science Teaching and
Learning in Lagos State Nigeria. PhD Thesis, Edith Cowan University, Perth
Australia.
24. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development {OECD} (2007). PISA
006: Science Competencies for Tomorrow s World (vol. 1). Paris: OECD.
25. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development –Global Science
Forum-OECD-GSF. (2006). Evolution of Student Interest in Science and Technology
Studies Policy Report. OECD: Paris.
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
113
John Fungulupembe Kalolo GLOBAL CHANGES IN SCIENCE EDUCATION (SE) AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS FOR SECONDARY
SCHOOL SCIENCE TEACHING AND LEARNING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
26. Osaki, K.M. (2007).The challenge of science and mathematics education in
Tanzania. Paper Presented at the Workshop to Launch the National Science INSET
Programme. Dar es Salaam: Ministry of Education and Vocational Training.
27. Osaki, K., Hosea, K. & Ottevanger, W. (Eds.) (2004). Reforming Science and
Mathematics Education in Sub-Saharan Africa: Obstacles and Opportunities. Dar es
Salaam: TEAMS, University of Dar es Salaam
28. Osborne, J., & Dillon, J. (2008).Science Education in Europe: Critical Reflections. A
Report to the Nuffield Foundation. Retrieved on March 2015 from,
http://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/fileLibrary/pdf/Sci_Ed_in_Europe_Report_Fi
nal.pdf
29. Reddy, V. (2006). Challenges to meet international Maths and Science standards,
HSRC Review, 4(1).
30. Srikanthan, G., & Dalrymple, J. (2003). Developing alternative perspectives for
quality in higher education. The International Journal of Educational Management,
17 (3), 126-36.
31. Stewart, V. (2010). A classroom as wide as the world. In Curriculum 21: Essential
Education for a Changing World, ed. H. Hayes Jacobs, 97–114. Alexandria, VA:
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
32. Symington, D., & Tytler, R. (2005). Designs on science: intelligent design merits
intelligent debate in schools. Australian (Canberra, A.C.T.). Nationwide News Pty
Limited, Canberra, A.C.T.
33. Tytler, R. (2007). Re-Imagining Science Education– Engaging Students in Science For
“ustralia s Future. Camberwell Vic: Australian Council for Educational. Cultural
discontinuity: Toward a quantitative investigation of a major hypothesis in
education. Educational Researcher, 37 (5), 280–297.
34. UNESCO, (2008).The Global Literacy Challenge. Paris, UNESCO.
35. UNICEF (2009). Child Friendly Schools. New York: UNICEF.
36. Wilmarth, S. (2010). Five socio-technology trends that change everything in
learning and teaching. In Curriculum 21: Essential Education for a Changing World,
ed. Heidi Hayes Jacobs, 80–96. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and
Curriculum Development.
Creative Commons licensing terms
Author(s) will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Education Studies shall
not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflicts of interest, copyright violations and
inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated into the research work. All the published works are meeting the Open Access
Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and non-commercial purposes
under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Education Studies - Volume 1 │ Issue 3 │ 2016
114