European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science
ISSN: 2501 - 1235
ISSN-L: 2501 - 1235
Available on-line at: www.oapub.org/edu
Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
doi: 10.5281/zenodo.1287320
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND
THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
Deepak Kem
Dr. Associate Professor,
Dr. KRN Centre for Dalit and Minorities Studies,
Jamia Millia Islamia,
New Delhi, 110025, India
Abstract:
World history has been characterized by periods such as Feudalism, Industrialism and
Capitalism that have served social scientists as tools to analyse and identify particular
societies. Similarly, the characteristic and defining feature of the contemporary society
is Information and Communicating Technology (ICT). Resultant to the ICT explosion
and application there has been radical transformation in education, corporate sector,
Government sector and most significantly, democracy is being reassessed. This paper
attempts to gaze into the social impacts of new media technologies assuming that in this
ICT dominant world human and social contexts of technology are undermined with an
assumption that ICT and its applications have the same meaning and consequences for
all. But recognizing the fact that social context plays a significant role in influencing ICT
and its applications in diverse ways, an attempt is also made to highlight the reciprocal
relationship between social context and information technology.
Keywords: new media technologies, social technical network
1. Introduction
The world has been characterized by determining phases that marks the development
of human societies over time, such as feudalism, industrialism, capitalism, socialism,
etc. These phases have served as important diagnostic apparatuses to identify typical
societies in the historical process as well as means to understand the elements of these
societies. They were characterized by specific nature of social relationships and
dominant ideologies that governed social life. Correspondingly, in a society dominated
Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved.
© 2015 – 2017 Open Access Publishing Group
653
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
by the information communication technologies and facing radical changes in its social
sphere, the social scientists today are struggling for the coinage of an appropriate
terminology to describe this post-modern society. Today, Information has become a
defining feature of our society and has come to be regarded as the icon of post-modern
society. The spread of technology and their convergence into the telecommunications
has led to the rise of new ways and means of work, new types of organizations and new
patterns of social relations. As a result of this work is undergoing radical
transformation, education is focused with new direction, corporate structures are
revitalized and even the very democratic structure is being reassessed. Drawn by these
changes, much attention is devoted to the understanding of information of social life.
With the contributions of scholarly research made in this regard from different
perspectives, new expressions are being brought to the fore front of social science
discourse and a systematic body of knowledge is being developed with new outlooks.
An assessment of this literature exposes that the sole focus is on technological
characteristics and their socio-economic repercussions. What this approach tends to
overlook is the vital rudiments like the societal and structural frameworks of
technology and the humans using them. The obvious underlying assumption of this
approach is that technological applications have same meaning to all users and have
similar consequences for all. Conversely, the users construe and encounter these
technical applications in their own manner. Here it would not be out of place to
mention that social contexts have a substantial influence on ICT applications, which in
turn has varied stimuli for working environment, the organization and social
relationships making Information Communication technologies not merely tools but a
new social and technical system. This paper proposes to analyse ICT’s as new form of
social technical systems taking into account the social impact and approaches for social
shaping embedded within it.
2. Understanding the Network System: Social and Technical
Much research on Information Technology began in
’s through the
’s with a
specific focus on the role of computerization in work places and organizations. The
main aim of such research was to explore the relationship between computer and its
impacts on various issues related to society. On one hand where research on computer
usage and social sciences gave weight age to issues concerning privacy, on the other
hand, business schools focused on behavioural information system, for instance, impact
of information system on decision-making, organizational structure and strategies for
designing information system. It was particularly in the
’s that a range of research
topics in this sphere opened up in these areas of IT and its use within an organization.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
654
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
During this span of time, questions relating to IT and its usage were considered
deterministic especially within the framework of a given organization and expected
behaviour, social life and superiority of work. Though these questions were simple and
direct, but the impacts were complex and varied. These ideas were mostly circulated
through the popular culture rather than in the dominant culture. In
’s with the
widespread use of IT in education through distance mode, managing knowledge,
online support formation, development of business process outsourcing (BPO) and ecommerce, it was realized that the association linking technologies and social change
are not simple and direct. This social impact perspective focuses only on technological
characteristics and their effects, in isolation from social and organizational contexts.
This is called technological determinism and this perspective makes faulty assumption
that all IT applications have similar connotation with universal implications. Social
informatics has been developed as a separate sphere of knowledge with a distinctive
perspective to overcome the limitations of the deterministic approach.
3. Social Informatics
A layman notion on "social informatics" may be with the intention of its concern as a
discipline that interests itself in understanding the impact of IT on social aspects. Kling
has provided a comprehensive definition by stating that Social informatics is the
interdisciplinary study of the design, uses and consequences of information technologies that
take into account their interaction with institutional and cultural contexts." Therefore as per
the classification provided by Kling it can safely be stated that social informatics is
concerned with exploring the impact of media associated technologies and the manner
that Information and communication technologies influence organizational behaviour
and societal relationships or the influence of social forces on the usage as well as design
age of such technology. It is important to understand that designing human interface
and internal structure is the essential element of social informatics as it provides the
change in emphasis from standard tool model to socio-technical model. This
perspective views Information Technology as socio-technical network and its
implementation as an on-going social process. As the present societies are so well
networked and interweaved, the technology being used and the society cannot be
viewed in isolation to each other, thereby leading us to realize that the developers of
these technologies never aimed neither the design nor its usage to be isolation. The ICT
applications, within the framework of socio-technical network embrace several
dimensions such as technological dimensions, people in a system, social relationships
and other system elements as interactive elements. Social informatics as socio-technical
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
655
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
model is distinguished from that of standard tool model as presented by Kling. R.
(2000).
4. ICT: Socio-Technical Network
ICT applications are customizable and they represent complex combination of standard
and customized elements. Even if same technology and equipment’s are provided to
different organizations, effects and consequences are varied, as each organization
develops its own socio-technical system that differs substantially from others. The
usage and consequences of an information system or ICT applications are profoundly
influenced by the particular character of an organization. There are many sectors that
have been impacted and benefitted from information technology. Though only a few
years old, ICT has affected essential and large sectors as communications, retail
business and has also penetrated into areas of education, health, management and
social life. This clearly suggests the all-in-one application of ICT within the perspective
of socio-technical network.
One of the most significant prospective for the ICT lies in redefining the
education system. Innovations in ICT have only complemented the craft of traditional
teaching rather than disregarding it. Indeed with the ICT being introduced in
educational institutions the responsibilities of the teacher has increased. In one role the
teacher is that of a service supplier for the students, who in turn are regarded as the
consumers. Teachers now have the provision for e-classrooms and sending over the
lessons for printing on student’s e-mails, during the course of the academic year. In the
initial and introductory stages of ICT in educational institutions, teachers did not use email for two reasons (a) they wanted to take the print out and read carefully before they
went into the class but there was no printing facility, and (b) with the upgradation of
the software, they became discouraged as they were forced to learn new software
procedures with each upgrade. Only after the teachers became technically sound
themselves and more facilities like printing options were added, they became more
comfortable to use Internet extensively.
In a study conducted in United States of America by Davidson, Schofield and
Stocks (2001) it was believed that Internet use would improve the quality of public
education and hence the USA government gave new computer laboratories and Internet
connections to all the schools. But due to the lack of appropriate support services and
training, teachers in many schools did not incorporate Internet services in teaching. But
it was found that wherever the support services were well organised, introduction of
Internet yielded good result in terms of innovation in teaching. Similarly, in the use of
Internet Applications, teachers differed from students. Teachers felt that computer
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
656
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
laboratories with Internet access were the means of scientific inquiry, whereas students
viewed it as chatting rooms and means of multi-players games. In Indiana University,
web boards were used to support classroom discussions. Proper usage of web boards
came into existence when certain social relationships were inscribed on web boards
regarding access controls as who can write and who can read, and with supporting
protocols about legitimate content.
In the above mentioned instances, the institutions and applications were initially
viewed as social forms, whereas the provision for Internet and web boards were treated
as technologies. Only when they had taken them together as constituent parts of sociotechnical networks, desired results were yielded. Therefore the reference to
technologies, entities and institutions are largely analytical and opportune knitting
together of the essential ICT elements the technical and the social.
5. ICT and Electronic Resources
In the present day, another impact of ICT can be seen of e-resources. For our
understanding, it is important to define electronic resources (or e-resources). In a very
simple language e-resources refer to such materials that are available in digital
format and are accessible electronically, such as e-journals, e-books, online databases
available in different digital formats, like pdf or htm, html, etc. Today these e-resources
are accessible in and from all libraries. Due the digitization of the print media, the
availability of books and journals in electronic format has increased for many. One of
the most unique features of e-resources is that it has the ability to incorporate multi
resources in one gadget. As the published content is also available on open access, this
helps the poor and underprivileged in getting the required information cost free. As
this information is available to them cost free, these e-resources facilitate and encourage
e-learning, assisted by the use of new media technologies.
Contrastingly, sturdy harmonies are that technological design alone cannot
ensure the good quality and content of the journal. Therefore, in order to in determine
the quality of any journal peer review has a vital role. This process of peer review is a
significant process with a meaningful social implication. The importance of social
technical approach can be understood by creation of a distinction between the design
and functioning” of e-journals as e-journals have several common features but one or
more may be more viable than the other.
Many e-resources provider review submitted articles in two phases. In the first
phase, submitted articles are open to discussion, on-line on their website. On the basis
of theses discussion online, the articles are revised by the authors and submitted for
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
657
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
review. In the second phase, on the basis of peer group review and quality measures
conducted confidentially, the articles are then accepted for publication.
In the case of other e-resource providers, instead of confidentiality bound review
system, a voting practice is adopted where comments and suggestions are invited and
offered. Two-tier acceptance with automatic review system in followed. All are allowed
to paste letters and authors are expected to answer them. The readers evaluate the
paper under review status adopting a weight-age system provided to control the range
of score given by a category of reader. Hereafter, these ranges of scores are converted to
databases that are averaged at month end deciding the ultimate position of the
submission consequently. Those submissions receiving score up to the defined average
score or higher are accepted for publication.
Though the acceptance of articles/content in case of both category of e-resource
provider may vary, the variation in their accomplishment is to an extent reliant on
individual social-technical interactive network designing. The designing is not just a
manufactured article or an object but the relationships that are reflected in the very
designing characteristics. “uthor’s participation in discussion with other researchers in
public forums is an important social element as it provides a forum to develop
discussions with readers and support as well as encouraging socio-technical system. It
is the designing that should not be technologically focused with mere provision of
automatic script and voting procedures, rather than allowing scholarly participation
and contribution.
6. ICT and Orgnizational Social-Technical Networking
An appropriate exploration of the ICT in our life can be validated with the help of
another instance related to the use of
computerized documentary system
in a
multinational company, Price Waterhouse which is a known international consulting
organization with thousands of operatives’ globally and at least a few thousand
employed at USA, itself. Though, many of them work in similar projects, they hardly
shared their information. So, the vice-president of the information systems had decided
to introduce Lotus Notes, the documentary support system, which is analogous to Internetlike system with bulletin boards, posting mechanisms, discussion groups and electronic mail of
the organization.”
The IT staff showed keen interest in it and used it assertively intended to share
data/information pertaining to their respective ventures, as they were technophiles.
They did not hesitate to invest their time in new applications because it was useful to
them for sharing information, documentary work and for communicating, as they had
common projects. Similarly, the Price Water consultants in Washington DC, according
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
658
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
to Mahler (1992) extensively used this technology and broadcasted to their tax
advisories. They observed the behaviour of the concerned Revenue officer and
accordingly advised their other offices in the country concerning tax modification and
changes in taxation legislation affecting their clients. Thus the tax consultants had
significant incentives to use the technology. As the use and importance has
appropriately been highlighted by Kirkpatrick (1993) that they wanted to be noticeable
and valued by their establishment and
Lotus Notes
provide them with the
opportunity to issue electronically, tax advisories quickly.
However, Orlikowski (1993) is of the observation that the seniors in the company
were the modest users of this technology. He points out that these consultants at this
job level had ample security hence were in a locus of experimentation with the new
technology and were enthusiastic to capitalise their time for exploring usage of e-mails
and sending memos. On the other hand, the junior level consultants who were called
associates did not show much interest and gave up after initial frustration. These
associates were assessed once in two years for promotion and 50% of them are fired out
at each review. They had billable hours and those who desired using Notes needed to
have an account from which they would be charged, for which no provision was made.
Otherwise, they had to spend about $3000 to $4500 @ rate of $150 per hour. They could
not justify their amount of expenditure on it and hence they hardly used the Notes .
7. Conclusion
Countless instances can be provided that are helpful to draw our interest to the use and
value of the IT and its significance in providing new means of communications to
support an abundance of human activities in every profession and organization.
Globally, the tools of New Media technologies have been accepted to be functional not
only for inter-personal communication but with the administrative organization. The
new media technologies are equally useful/helpful in shopping, investment purposes,
entertainment etc for all age groups. Similarly, Kahin and Keller, (1995) state many
other instances where the tools facilitate the public to better access to important
information.
The above analysis with the help of few examples is an attempt to provide a
framework for the emerging ICT based socio-technical network where elements such as
human resource in their different capacities and their inter personal relationships as
well as the system, the software, the Hardware, the support resources, information
structures, network, network content, etc. become the constituent parts.
These elements are interconnected, especially with their socio-technical
dependencies within the matrix. A system designer who is technical, with a social
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
659
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
orientation is in a better position to identify and incorporate features and trade-offs
which appeal most to the end-users. As Simonsey and Kensing (1997) have observed
workplace ethnography is another discovery process in this field of study. Similarly
Bolsstrom and Heinen (1997) and Carmel, et al (1993) have suggested the use of focus
groups user participation in designing teams and Schuler and Namioka (1993) and
Eckehard et al
prefer learning about people’s preferences through participatory
design strategies. The socio-technical orientation has the potential to prevent
conventional misuse and dispel lost optimism. Correspondingly, it is interesting and
equally noteworthy that the various available perspectives of this discipline have
important implications for policy making, practicing professionalism and information
centres.
These applications of new media are designed by outside vendors and tend go
according to their best practices. Those organizations which have incorporated the
usage of new media applications in order to work with designs will either have to
adopt newer practices or will have to do away with their current/older practices. These
designers should appreciate the work, work process, system, system elements and
working conditions of the end users. Any kind of alienation from the design process
will lead to failure in the applications. User-oriented perspective is absolutely essential
for effective application and to design right technology. The social–informatics attempts
to address all these issues with idiosyncratic perspectives of socio-technical network
system.
Bibliography
1. Bolstrom, Robert.P and J.S. Heinen, 1997 M.S Problems and Failures: A Socio
Technical Perspective, Part I: The Causes, MIS Quarterly, 1(3) 11-28.
2. Carnel, Erram, Ravidall D. Whitaker, and Joey F. Gerage
. PD and Joint
“pplication Design: “ Trans “tlantic Comparison , Communications of the ACM
June 36 (6) 40-48.
3. Davidson, Schofield and Stocks,
. Professional Cultures and Collaborative
Efforts: A case study of Technologists and Educators working for Change , The
information Society 17(1).
4. Eckchard, Doerry, Sarah A. Dougles, Author E. Kirkpatric, Monte Westerfield,
, Participatory Design for Widely – Distributed Scientific Communities,
http://www.unwest.Com/webconference.
5. Kahin and Keller, 1995. Kahin, Brian and James Keller, (Eds.) 1995. Public Access
to the Internet. Cambridge, Ma: MIT Press.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
660
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
6. Kirkpatric David, 1993, Groupware goes boom: Effects of Groupware Software
packages on Corporations, Fortune Die 128(16) 99-103.
7. Kling, R. 1999. What is Social Informatics and Why Does it Matter? D-Lib
Magazine. 5 (1) at http://www.dlib.org:80/dlib/january99/kling/01kling.html.
8. Kling, Rob 2000. Learnign about Information Technologies and Social Change:
The Contribution of Social Informatics, The Information Society 16(3).
9. Mahler Mark, 1992. Notes Fanatic, Corporate Computing, August (2) 160-164.
10. Orlikowski, Wanda J. 1993. Learning from Notes: Organisational Issues in
Groupware Implementation, The Information Society. Step a (3).
11. Schuler. Doug and Narmika, 1993. Participatory Design: Principles and Practices.
Hillsdale, N.J: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
12. Simonsen, Jesper and Finn kensing. 1997, Using Ethnography in Contextual
Design, Communication of the ACM, July 40 (7) 82-88.
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
661
Deepak Kem
NEW MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES AND THE EMERGING SOCIAL TECHNICAL NETWORK
Creative Commons licensing terms
Authors will retain the copyright of their published articles agreeing that a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) terms
will be applied to their work. Under the terms of this license, no permission is required from the author(s) or publisher for members of the community
to copy, distribute, transmit or adapt the article content, providing a proper, prominent and unambiguous attribution to the authors in a manner that
makes clear that the materials are being reused under permission of a Creative Commons License. Views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this
research article are views, opinions and conclusions of the author(s). Open Access Publishing Group and European Journal of Physical Education and
Sport Science shall not be responsible or answerable for any loss, damage or liability caused in relation to/arising out of conflict of interests, copyright
violations and inappropriate or inaccurate use of any kind content related or integrated on the research work. All the published works are meeting the
Open Access Publishing requirements and can be freely accessed, shared, modified, distributed and used in educational, commercial and noncommercial purposes under a Creative Commons attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 3 │ Issue 12 │ 2017
662